Walmart Inc (WMT)

Doesn’t have the confirmation of volume to warrant the large drop in 2015. This did so well for so long, and the big drop with no volume indicates it has been completely oversold.

They have been the victim of their business mix. 50% of their margin comes from groceries. He would stand aside. It has not been the great American success story for the last couple of years.

It is pretty tough in the consumer space right now. It is very competitive and there seems to be a preference for buying hard goods versus apparel type of goods. Earnings growth is slowing. This company is large, so it is harder to grow when you are coming from a large base. Last quarter they announced they were making a lot of future investments for future growth.

This has not been growing and it is too big to grow. That is one of its problems. We haven’t seen any follow-through from clients in the store, because they are not driving to the store. The company’s Internet strategy is weak compared to others. This could be a failed retail story.

If you have a long term horizon then it is okay to get in now. They are unrivaled and continue to do well. They are so spread out that they are now having trouble growing their business. This turn-around will take 2-5 years.

This company is not going to be growing their revenues for the next couple of years because of some issues such as a lot of CapX that they had to spend and rising wage costs. Revenue has not been a solid as you would think. With their large store format, they are not getting as much efficiencies, and same-store sales have not done as well. They are getting a lot of competition from e-commerce.

(Top Pick Nov 25/14, Down 31.08%) He still has HD-N, but along the way it became clear that secular growth was the most attractive in this market. Part way through the year he rotated to AMZN-Q.

Has a few headwinds. First is the FX. 30% of revenues come from outside the US. Secondly, labour costs are going up with them. They need to try to keep the people they have on staff on board, and their wages are moving higher. Another thing that is affecting this company is their foray into more of the e-commerce type of space, and trying to compete against companies like Amazon, etc. That is going to cost them money. The long-term growth rate is looking pretty paltry at about a single digit growth rate.

CEO came out with a warning for the next couple of years talking about slow growth, and the stock has been in a downward struggle at the same time. It conceptually makes sense that if you get all the bad news out, something should help along the way. A lot of that has already been baked into the price. There is a negative cloud hanging over this and you want to see something that has a positive stimulus. Technically it is in a downward trading channel. On top of that, we are no longer in the seasonal period for consumer staples.

This has struggled a lot of late. It caters to people in the lower half of the income demographics. While he is still thinks it is a great retailer, it is just not growing very much and it is very hard to turn it around. E-commerce is eating away at it. It has benefited from lower fuel costs, but he just doesn’t see an identifiable catalyst to get it growing.

It has struggled this year, down about 25%. He likes what they are doing in terms of a go forward strategy. They plan to open more stores. They are now price matching the prices of on-line retailers. They are getting into the organic side in groceries. They will be taking their customers up the price scale to more expensive products. He is not in a rush to buy this name, however. See how the initiatives play out.

This bottomed out in valuation in 2008. He has a model price of $85.53, a 28% upside and there is support. There is an incredible amount of value here, but the market doesn’t care, because it is not growing.

For a long-term investor, this is probably a reasonable entry point. It has been a tough couple of years for them, but he thinks they are making all the right moves to improve the earnings pace. They keep buying back a lot of stock and raising the dividend every year.

There has been a lot of discussion about Wal-mart and Costco. Wal-mart made its 52 week low. He doesn’t pick bottom or devalues. The dollar stores have fundamentally changed the backdrop for Wal-mart. Thinks that there are better places to be.

The problem for her is that this company really has been growth. One of the concerns is on the labour side and their costs going up. They have always been pretty good at managing those costs, but overall, for a company of that size, it is hard to get more than a GDP plus a little bit of a story. The consumer has been very selective. Where they have been spending their money is on their houses.