
TSE:MG
This summary was created by AI, based on 5 opinions in the last 12 months.
Magna International (MG-T) has had a tumultuous journey, with heavy investments in electric vehicles (EVs) in 2021 not yielding the expected demand, resulting in significant challenges and the impact of tariffs. However, the company has managed to address its issues with Chinese OEMs and is currently experiencing a notable market share increase in smart door handles and driverless systems. Recent financial results have surprised analysts positively, indicating a strong recovery, although concerns over the continuity of this momentum exist due to potential headwinds from the CUSMA agreement. The auto supply chain’s complexities suggest that investors should assess the cyclical nature of the industry carefully while considering ownership of the stock, especially as it could face further volatility tied to economic conditions and tariff discussions.
Down today because of NAFTA concerns. That is going to be a risk, not just for Canada and Mexico, but it’s really a global risk. This is cheap, trading at 8-9 times Forward Earnings. A cyclical name, but they’ve done very well in capturing more of the car. Sold his holdings a while ago because of concerns with NAFTA. Felt the risk was greater than the reward going forward. Dividend yield of 1.93%, which is not high enough to make him want to take on that NAFTA risk.
He worries a little about this whole space. Auto parts in general are obviously a part of the Canadian market that could be severely impacted by NAFTA. The whole industry would be disrupted significantly. On a valuation basis, this doesn't look expensive. He would avoid it because of near peak auto sales in North America and the NAFTA risk.
He likes all the auto parts. He has owned this one for 5 years. It has always been cheap but now it also has good price momentum. It scores in the top 3% in terms of valuation. 21% ROE. 10 times PE. They are starting to split out their various divisions when reporting and this makes it easier for analysts. Activist investors might pressure them to spin out some of their dividends. (Analysts’ target: $65.00).
(A Top Pick Feb 15/17. Up 29%.) This has done well on the back of very strong Canadian auto sales. More importantly, where they sell to European vehicles, those are still coming along nicely. In the US, hurricanes created more replacement demand than had been expected. The company has done a great job of outgrowing the overall auto industry, and are doing that by getting more content into each vehicle. At the Detroit Auto Show, they forecasted $6 billion of free cash flow over the next 3 years.
Regarding concerns on NAFTA, no one knows what Trump is going to do. He thinks it is a bit of a red herring. Behind the scenes there is a lot of support. 95% of US businesses want to keep NAFTA in place. There is already a NAFTA discount in the whole auto sector, which has created really cheap valuations. This is trading at 7X earnings. Thinks it continues to grow at double digits for the next several years, even in a flat to slightly down North American auto market. It is a leader in autonomous driving technology. Dividend yield of 1.9%. (Analysts' price target is $65.)
There is a NAFTA concern which has kept him on the sidelines, but he is more concerned for the next couple of years on car sales, Peak Auto. There are also some issues on consumer car credits. Electric vehicles is a 10-year story, but will slowly eat into some business. He wants to see a good 1.5 years, to see where car sales are. If you own this, you might consider selling your holdings and looking at something else for the next 6 months to a year.
This company has done quite well. Auto production in the US has been very strong for the past year. Hurricanes in October-November, added a bit of additional demand. Auto parts suppliers tend to all trade at low multiples. She expects we will not see much in higher unit sales in the US. Growth has to come from Europe, and maybe China. We have NAFTA coming up, and those negotiations have not been progressing. If NAFTA gets dismantled, that is a negative for the auto industry.
Thinks the industrial space is going to do well in 2018. It goes with the whole global growth phenomena that is occurring. You are going to have a lot of demand from economies across the world. This is the kind of company that should be able to benefit from this. The stock is cheap on pretty much every metric you can look at. Nice dividend. They are buying back shares. Dividend yield of 2%.
Chart shows a fairly decent up channel from early 2016. The question is, will we break above the old high. Because the up channel is so well-established, he thinks there is a decent chance of breaking out above the old highs. The last 2 days of price declines are still way above the middle of the up-channel. This is a buying opportunity.
Linamar (LNR-T) vs Magna (MG-T) vs Martinrea (MRE-T) Has a small position in Magna (MG-T) which is the largest of the three. At this point in the auto cycle in North America, would be very hesitant about adding more. Thinks the bump up in number of vehicles in North America is plateauing. Very cyclical. You can see earnings and cash flow really degrade quickly rapidly. It’s one he would be careful and look for opportunities to sell on strong.
A lot of his customers are worried about NAFTA. It has been dragging on for so long, and meanwhile this company keeps hitting new highs every other day. Feels it is starting to be valued as if NAFTA is going to go away. They have lots of European business which he wouldn't be concerned about. Has a fabulous balance sheet. If they are worried about the N.A. market, they can totally go into any other country and make a really big acquisition. Even if NAFTA is thrown out, investors just like certainty. They can't really value things properly because they don't know what is going to happen. This company could go either way. This will pass over time and they will just keep growing.