
NASDAQ:COST
This summary was created by AI, based on 53 opinions in the last 12 months.
Experts have mixed opinions about Costco Wholesale Corporation (COST), highlighting its strong business model and consistent growth, yet expressing concerns over its high price-to-earnings (PE) ratio, which is currently above 45. Some analysts admire its resilience in the consumer staples sector, especially in challenging economic times, emphasizing the company's ability to add store locations and its strong membership model. However, a significant number of reviewers indicate that the stock remains overvalued given its historical performance metrics and express a desire for a pullback before considering re-entry or additional purchases. Potential investors are advised to wait for a more favorable PE ratio or a market correction as a means to achieve better long-term returns.
Can this compete with Amazon (AMZN-Q)? If there is one name that can compete with them, it is this one. They are able to cross sell products. It is one of the few retailers that has done exceptionally well. Trading at around 28X PE, which is expensive, but continues to set new highs and go higher. Dividend yield of about 1.25%. A tough place to be if the stock goes sideways. About 25% of revenue comes from membership fees, which is a little bit of concern, because with 80 million members, how much more can they grow in this area.
The world’s 2nd largest retailer by revenue, and operate over 700 stores and warehouses globally. They have 90 million member cardholders. He doesn’t believe the acquisition of Whole Foods by Amazon (AMZN-Q) will change the game that rapidly for this company. Renewal rates are 90% in North America and 88% outside of North America. They need to improve their online revenues which are still in single digits. Dividend yield of 1.3%. (Analysts’ price target is $185.37.)
Retailers in general have been pretty stressed. They continue to miss earnings, and are hurting because of Amazon (AMZN-Q). This one is not quite in the same category as they have a bit of a moat. They are the leader in the membership model of large packaging and deeper discounting. Trading at a pretty good valuation. Good ROE’s up 22%. OK on a PE basis. Thinks this will be one of the survivors.
Bricks and mortar retail in general has been under pressure all year. He has focused on Internet retailers such as Amazon (AMZN-Q). However, he does have a small holding on this one. It has a pretty defendable position in the big box club stores. Just dropped 10%, and he is not happy to see anything drop that much. This is basically trading right on its 200-day moving average. When Amazon acquired Whole Foods, every retailer within shooting distance, got taken out to the woodshed. He would use a 200-day moving average as a Stop. In the short run, there was a knee-jerk rejection, and some companies will likely rise out of that. Feels this company is less likely to be hurt than some of the other big grocers.
A great franchise. Doing very well in North America and in their expansion plans elsewhere. Has never owned this. Has a forward PE ratio of about 28-29 times, which is at the high point of its 10-year historical average. That concerns him a little. It has a growth rate of about 10%, so you are looking at a stock that is rather expensive when looking at the PEG ratio. It continues to move well in price action, but from a valuation standpoint, you want to be careful and look at other names instead.
What you need to know when buying a stock in the retail sector is how they are going to be affected by Amazon (AMZN-Q). Amazon is changing the world as we know it. Costco is a company that can and does compete with Amazon on price. He likes this company, but there is another name he likes better. (See Top Picks.)
This model is fantastic. Basically, they make nothing on the merchandise they sell and 100% of their profitability comes from membership fees. Retailers are out of fashion right now, especially brick and mortar ones, because of the new age of ordering online and e-commerce as well as border tax implications. Only about 25% of their merchandise comes from outside the US borders, so they are somewhat insulated. People pay up for it, so the PE is somewhere in the high 20s. If they continue doing what they are doing, a mid-20s multiple is reasonable. He would not be comfortable paying this multiple for his clients.
An outstanding business model. It is e-commerce resilient. The unit economics are very, very strong. A very durable moat type business. They make a ton of money on membership fees, and are about to increase them in July, which will be a nice earnings tailwind. However, it always comes back to what you want to pay for it. He is waiting for a better entry point. Dividend yield of about 1.1%.
One of the leaders in the low-cost space. Their margins run at about half of what their competitors do. That model only works if there is high turnover of your products. They have been successful in picking the right products, pricing them and moving them very quickly. The risk is, if you do get into a slowdown, there really isn’t any room to cut prices. They generate about 25% of revenue from membership fees, and with so many members, it is difficult to grow revenue. Membership fees are going up, which is a way to have that side of the business stay strong. Trading at about 29X Price to Earnings. For him, the dividend trajectory growth is not there, and trades too rich for him. Dividend yield of 1.1%.