
TSE:X
There are fears that the big US guys are coming over and beating them up and taking over. The higher-ups in the company are denying that that is a possibility. There is some support that was pretty dominant in the low $40 or so, and that looks like it was broken as it is falling like a rock. When it starts consolidating, that is a sign that maybe the end of that trend is over. He would avoid this for the time being.
This is a little volatile because there is not a lot of float out there. If you look at the holders, it is pensions and banks, so the amount of floating stock is very little. The valuation is much cheaper than the other North American publicly traded exchanges. Spitting out tons of free cash flow. There is potential for a dividend increase. He doesn’t view this as a financial, but as an annuity revenue stream technology company at a very reasonable valuation. His Fair Value price target is about $75. This is a show-me story and they have to deliver over the next 2 years.
The 1st quarter has not been great in terms of trading, but this is not just a trading company. There are listing fees, advisory fees, and technology fees. Listing fees have been huge recently because there have been a lot of preferred shares and secondary offerings for oil and gas companies that need the money. He is hopeful that there will be more IPOs. Trading at around 12 or 13 times next year’s earnings. Dividend yield of 3.04%, which is the highest dividend yield relative to its US peers.
Chart shows a nice upper trend from mid-2011, which is moving higher. There was a peak in 2013 and another this year. This is not a perfect double top. Certainly an area where it caused some sellers to come out about a year and a half ago. You may have that happen now. You don’t want to see it go down to $55 because that could bring it down to the $45 range. Expects weakness in the near-term.
CEO is stepping down. He is glad of this as he was very disappointed in his reign. Would like to see this company get reconnected to the Canadian financial industry. He thinks it should be an absolutely integral part of the Canadian financial scene. Hopefully we’ll get someone who is more interested in growing the TMX in the context of a growing Canada. Not a great stock at this point in time to invest in and there is better value in the marketplace. The exchange world has changed. Easy money in this area was made 7-10 years ago.
If we think equity markets will do okay, exchange companies will do just fine. He would prefer to look outside of Canada because Canada’s makeup on the index probably is likely to see us underperform going forward for the next little while in the absence of a very robust recovery which might get our cyclicals going. Doesn’t think you will get hurt in this one as he expects equity markets are going to continue to perform pretty well.
Some big investors recently cashed out, which gave him an opportunity to buy more. It is a network business, an exchange. A monopoly generating about 75% revenue from trading, and 100% of revenue from listings. It has a fixed cost operation, so as trading increases, there is more listings. As the market goes higher, all of that falls to the bottom line. That happened in the last quarter, and more of that will continue as the market improves. Thinks there is opportunity for it to trade at a 16 or 17 times PE. Dividend yield of 2.81%.