
TSE:SU
Suncor (SU-T) or Canadian Natural Resources (CNQ-T)? Both companies, relative to the other stocks in the energy index, have performed pretty well. From this point on, he likes both, and is hard-pressed to tell you which he would choose. Both have very good growth profiles. They are both very good on M&A on an opportunistic basis. Balance sheets have been improving steadily. This one is bringing Fort Hills on stream by the end of this year, which will be a significant contributor to cash flow growth. Because they have both held their ground so well, there are better opportunities in some of the intermediate space, in terms of capital gains.
The period of seasonal strength for energy stocks is from January to May of each year. We have now passed the period of seasonal strength for energy, and it has a tendency to either go flat or lower. This is not a time when you want to be an owner. The time for repurchasing the stock would be probably in January.
Not a big fan of energy. Canada is the high cost producer at the end of the pipeline, and this company is at the end of that pipeline. They own assets that have been bankrupt 2 or 3 times in the past, so they don’t have cash depreciation costs on a lot of them. Cost per barrel is in the $20-$25 range, so they are getting cash flow, but they are really not covering depreciation on the plants. He wouldn’t own this.
Buy, Sell or Hold? This has had excellent production growth since 2014. Their major projects remain on track. Their recent earnings were in line. He is modelling 10% production growth 2017-2019. 4% cash flow per share growth. Good balance sheet. The payout ratio for 2017 is about 109%. A blue-chip name in the Canadian oil space.
(A Top Pick March 2/17. Down 3.67%.) The period of seasonal strength for some of these energy stocks, this one in particular, is from late January all the way through to mid-May. The average gain for that time frame is about 14.6%, and has been positive 75% of the time over the past 20 years. This was probably the only oil/energy stock that was positive over that time frame.
If you want exposure to energy, but don’t want to lose your shirt if oil prices go down, this is the way to do it. Year-to-date oil is down about 10%, and this one is down about 5%. A good way to participate. It is integrated. They are exploring, refining and selling it at the pumps. A conservative way to play energy. Dividend yield of 3%. (Analysts’ price target is $50.)
He is dramatically underrepresented in the “energy producer” sector, and wants to get money back into oils. The best place to start is in a big cap liquid name that pays a dividend. He is not looking for torque yet, because he can’t quite see the beauty of the recovery, but he wants to have exposure, simply because on a value basis these things are cheap and this is levered to oil, and has actually outperformed oil in its existence. Dividend yield of 3%. (Analysts’ price target is $50.)
Oil is very cyclical on very long cycles. The last time oil rallied big time was in the 1970s when Japan industrialized. It rallied again when China industrialized. China appears to be done industrializing. The commodity infrastructure has been built globally, up to a point where we can supply the demand for energy. We have had technology changes that have allowed for the shale plays to come. The US mid-continent is loaded with shale oil and companies are able to produce the stuff for sub-$50 a barrel. There are millions and millions of barrels that can be brought on. The other big play that is happening is in the Marsalis shale in Ohio, which is hammering gas and natural gas liquids. Energy is going to be under assault for a long time. On top of that you have shales in other parts of the world and the technology will be transferable. Also, a lot of oil producing countries need money, so you are going to see a lot of oil coming at you. This company, unfortunately, is the high cost oil, the dirtiest oil, at the end of the pipeline. They will survive, because their cash costs are about $25 a barrel. He wouldn’t put his money here for the next 10 years.