Stockchase Opinions

Stockchase InsightsShopify Inc.SHOP.TOHOLDMar 14, 2025

Trevor Rose’s Insights - Trevor’s most-liked answers from 5i Research

The stock has been volatile, as all growth stocks have been recently. We think merchant customers and the company can adapt well enough. However, the consumer spending impact of tariffs remains a variable. Consumer confidence has dropped, and if tariffs induce inflation then business may certainly be negatively impacted overall. Silver linings might be valuation (better of course with the decline) and sentiment (market sentiment is so bad currently any good news could amplify moves). It remains a high Beta stock. Down 11% YTD, it has actually held up better than many others.
Unlock Premium - Try 5i Free

$136.33

Stock price when the opinion was issued

$162.85

As of Jun 02, 2026. Market Open.

0
It's the ideal tool to help you make quicker, more informed decisions for managing and tracking your investments.

You might be interested:

BUY

Everybody hates software now, because apparently AI will replace it. But SHOP was innovative, quick to roll out services to include AI. They are seeing some growth. Is a high-growth company. Doesn't worry much about it. Now is a good buying opportunity. Is a growth stock.

DON'T BUY

Very volatile. A great company with growth, but the valuation is too high and shares are priced to perfection. That decline just happened after reporting recently. Anything software has been hit by AI fears.

BUY

CEO is very focused and hands-on AI. In the future, a lot more commerce will be agentic. Revenue model will shift increasingly to subscription-based. One of the names in the space he likes. Founder led, and the guy knows AI.

DON'T BUY

Good products and growth. The numbers they reported last week were fine, but future growth is moderating, which the markets doesn't like, consider its high PE. 

DON'T BUY

Gets painted as sort of a software company, and those are out of favour. Price action is very difficult, and often feels like trying to catch a knife. His price target is ~$205. There are so many other clear opportunities out there than trying to wing it with this one.

WAIT

Quite volatile. On her watchlist. One of the strongest platforms in the e-commerce space. Total value of goods sold expected to grow 32%. AI already helping merchants attract customers.

Be patient for a favourable entry point to get in.

(Analysts’ price target is $189.00)
DON'T BUY

At its core, it's the software between drop-shippers in China and influencers/users. So it's in the layer that's more at risk over time. If it were cheaper, he'd be more interested.

MSFT is the better pick today.

TRADE

People think large-language models will eat its lunch, make the e-commerce platform questionable. Many analysts have brought down 12-month price targets. Volatility gives you a chance to earn income by selling puts and calls. 

(Analysts’ price target is $159.00)
DON'T BUY

He loves their business, which has few competitors, but the problem is always their high valuation, even after the current pullback. They have low free cash flow. Too risky. You're playing momentum either way.

TOP PICK

Winning the global commerce infrastructure war. Valuation is always the hurdle for investors. Has a real moat and real fundamentals. CEO has an AI-first approach, which helps to expand margins. No dividend.

(Analysts’ price target is $157.00)

WAIT

Really well managed. Can they anchor themselves in an agentic-commerce world? Making every attempt to do so. But will they succeed? Too soon to know. Market-darling, cult-like stocks facing existential questions usually have valuations compress more. Probably more downside risk.

DON'T BUY

Tech is struggling and SHOP trades at a high PE. Would be interesting in the $80s. He sees more downside from here.

TRADE

Dropped below 200-day MA -- have to watch that. Always pricier than many names, and so he's never owned. Trailing PE is 133x, forward PE is 69x. Caters to small and medium businesses, which are more quickly affected by changes in the economy.

High beta (almost 2x that of the TSX) and volatile profile make it a trading stock.

BUY

One of the highest-growth, highest-quality businesses in Canada. Pretty attractive entry point. Expensive. Volatile, so expect 20% drawdown short-term. New products, cross-selling, up-selling. Leading edge of integrating AI.

WATCH

A name to look at in the beaten-up software space.