Stockchase Opinions

Stockchase InsightsCostco Wholesale CorporationCOSTBUY ON WEAKNESSMay 29, 2023

Trevor Rose’s Insights - Trevor’s most-liked answers from 5i Research.

EPS of $3.42 beat estimates of $3.28. Sales of $53.6B slightly missed estimates of $54.26B. Costco's top-line growth in fiscal 4Q may be driven more by traffic as the average basket size declines, though same-store sales excluding fuel and foreign exchange face tough comparisons. Food and sundries are categories of strength. Management expects inflation to moderate in 4Q, though lower demand for big-ticket items like furniture and electronics remains a headwind that will persist. The company discontinued its charter shipping activities in 3Q, resulting in a non-recurring charge that's weighing on profit. Core merchandise margin may be pressured in fiscal 4Q from higher costs and lower sales of higher-margin discretionary items. Investors liked the results, and the stock remains one that could still do well in a recessionary environment. Valuation is certainly up there at 35X earnings, but it has never been a cheap stock. 
Unlock Premium - Try 5i Free

$507.26

Stock price when the opinion was issued

$918.33

As of Oct 01, 2026. Market Open.

department stores
It's the ideal tool to help you make quicker, more informed decisions for managing and tracking your investments.

You might be interested:

HOLD

Last Thursday they reported a healthy top and bottom line beat, 15% earnings growth, worldwide membership renewals increased to 89%, executive memberships doubled to a record level, now accounting for 75.6% of all sales. But total membership growth slowed again. Membership under age 40 has grown nearly 60% since Covid. Web business, small appliances, home furnishings are growing. He hasn't a convincing story from management about how to get younger customers who signed up online to renew. Trades at 40x PE.

PARTIAL BUY

Their latest numbers were good, but the PE is always high. Is up 6.5% this year. Note: the under-40 membership has climbed 60% since Covid. Costco will face pressure from tariffs and higher prices. Like it a lot, but don't rush into it now.

DON'T BUY

Still fairly pricey, around 40x PE. 

See his Top Picks for a less expensive option.

COMMENT

They report Thursday. The stock is acting poorly. They have troubles getting younger people to sign up for memberships, because the young prefer shopping online.

DON'T BUY

Fantastic company, but still very expensive. Consistent, well-managed. Expectations for growth are about 10%, which doesn't entitle you to a 45x PE in his world. It's done well and good for them, but he can't get involved.

TOP PICK

World's third-largest retailer. High traffic, repeat business, superior same-store sales growth in high single digits. Likes the recurring membership fees, with ~92% retention rate. Likes the procurement clout and narrow assortment of goods. Pretty good gross margins of 11%, and ~30% ROE. 

Seems to trade at a high multiple, and this scares people. But it's compounded at 17-18% since the IPO in 1985. Any day that ends in "y" is a good day to buy. Yield is 0.64%.

(Analysts’ price target is $1093.58)
WEAK BUY

You have to be get used to paying a PE for this, like Walmart (which he prefers). A $50 drop off $1,100 is meaningless, since it has more room to run. 

TOP PICK

Has traded at a high valuation pretty much since it went public. Good luck trying to pick a perfect valuation entry point. He invests in companies that can invest cashflows at high rates of return over decades. Stealing market share from low- and middle-end grocery stores. Adding services, such as Medicare plans in the US. Same-store sales growth 7-8% a year.

Deserves to trade at a high multiple because of business durability over the long term. Yield is 0.60%.

(Analysts’ price target is $1095.57)
BUY ON WEAKNESS

A better growth name than ATD. Take a look.

COMMENT

It's one of the best business on Earth. Customers and employees love Costco. They are opening new stores, so there's ample runway. However, the PE of around 44x is high. Same-store sales growth has slowed slightly. But it's good to hold long term.

BUY ON WEAKNESS

It got too expensive, and now trades at 46x PE. If it falls to 45x expects a major move higher. Has long owned this.

DON'T BUY

He sold it last October at $1015. The chart began to break down. 

PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Apr 03/25, Up 0.55%)

Inflation is really hard out there. Real pressure to save money, and this name is among the low-cost providers. Sees it continuing to do well, despite a difficult environment for so many people.

PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Sep 02/25, Up 4%)

High valuation but is growing double digits, which it should do so for years. They have the lowest prices of products compared to peers. A lot of room to expand location. A great business model. He will hold this forever.

PARTIAL BUY

Buy some now at 47x PE, then more at 45x. Likes it. Is up 13% this year