TSE:IFC

Intact Financial (IFC.TO)

294.25
-0.92 (0.31%)
as of Jul 16, 2026, 8:00:00 pm Market Open.
379 watching
0
Investor Insights
star iconJul 16, 2026, 12:00 am

This summary was created by AI, based on 18 opinions in the last 12 months.

Intact Financial Corporation (IFC-T) has received mixed reviews from industry experts. Some analysts highlight the company's strong fundamentals and potential for growth, particularly in a rising interest rate environment, viewing it as a long-term hold despite recent market fluctuations. The stock, however, is noted to be trading below its 200-day moving average, indicating a downward trend, and some experts caution that growth has plateaued, making it less attractive compared to peers. Valuations vary, with opinions suggesting the company is either fairly valued or slightly overvalued, yet still offering a decent yield. Overall, while it appears to have solid management and position within the P&C insurance sector, there are concerns regarding future profitability and competitive pricing pressures.

consensus icon
Consensus
Hold
valuation icon
Valuation
Fair Value
review icon
Similar
AFG, AFG
COMMENT
It's done quite well and dominates market position in P&C insurance. They can always reprice their products. It trades at a higher valuation vs. its peers. Maybe its growth is higher. But their valuation has always kept her on the sidelines.
TOP PICK
Has an 18% market share in Canada for P&C insurance, the biggest. They recently dipped into America with an acquisition. They boast a 9% compund growth rate in earnings. (Analysts’ price target is $117.54)
PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Feb 26/18, Up 16%) Half their business is auto and costs were going up because cars got more expensive to fix. They are doing fine in auto now as the insurance industry has been able to raise their rates.
TOP PICK

In Q2 they showed progress in personal auto profit, and their OneBeacon acqusition. Their combined ratio beat guidance. He sees EPS growth. It's very cheap at 13x earnings. It hasn't come off as much as its peers. It's a beacon of safety, a steady Eddy. This is a late-cycle business play. (2.79% dividend yield, Analysts' price target: $112.46)

HOLD

Insurance companies do better in a rising interest rate environment. It is one of the better stocks in terms of price momentum and it is stable. Valuation, though, is a little high for him at 19 times earnings. They are well within their payout ratio, however. There are no balance sheet concerns, but he can find better alternatives in the space, making it a hold. See his pas picks today for a better alternative.

STRONG BUY

14x earnings and has historically grown earnings at 12% compounded over the last decade. The market is hardening with price increases to feed margins. They recently acquired an American specialty operation that will be synergistic and will lead to more M&A in the U.S. Also, they outearn their peers wqith 12-14% ROE. They are serial acquirers and will continue this. Have 17% market share. Interest rates will be a further boost. Lots of runway ahead. Lots of good things happening here.

TOP PICK

They missed the mark on Q1 on weaker auto and weather. They are modeling growing earnings at 20%. Trading at 11.9 times 2019. Fragmented space. (Analysts’ price target is $107.61)

WATCH

He does not own it, but he is watching closely with the recent pullback. It is extremely well run, but operates on thin margins. He would wait until after the Ontario election, because insurance rates can be a political football. It has a good long term future. (Analysts’ price target is $108 )

TOP PICK

It has superior results to Canadian peers. The accident rate has not been lowering because of backup cameras. Profits will improve and the stock will go up. (Analysts’ target: $107.77).

PAST TOP PICK

(A Top Pick June 16/17 - Up 2.7%) Sold around ¾ of his positions. They have some personal auto weakness. Management is committed to turnaround. Good name over time.

DON'T BUY

He's surprised they've done so well, because they've missed several quarters, partly due to bad weather hurting their bottom line. IFC had great growth through acqusition years ago, but they've been disappointing lately. He'd rather buy a lifeco, not a P&C company,

BUY

He prefers this to Manulife. They have been a consistent operator over time. They have gone through some softness in their quarters, especially in their auto division, but he expects them to raise rates soon to address this.

TOP PICK

Has been going up for 10 years. It is targeting 10% growth every year. It has pulled back recently but has a steady business model. (Analysts’ target: $110.35).

COMMENT

Switch bank stocks to this company? This is going to be a little more volatile than the banks. It has been a great, long term stock. Every time there is a natural disaster, everyone is worried about what is going to happen, and they just increase their premiums, and make more money the following year.

BUY

It is in the top 16% of his database. Earnings growth is expected to be 18% this year. The fundamentals support the break out.

Showing 106 to 120 of 256 entries