Stock price when the opinion was issued
ATH vs HSE vs MEG? The clear stand out is MEG, who is 55% hedged at $59 oil prices. ATH has a high cost project with Hangingstone and is burning cash, although they have enough liquidity for the next 9 months. He would never own HSE, because of their ESG issues. All bets are off for all of them if $25 oil prices remain in 2021.
There are better things out there. You need to be more defensive in the energy sector. At some point oil is definitely going higher. This one has upstream, downstream and gas stations, but he would prefer others like SU-T.