
TSE:CTC.A
This summary was created by AI, based on 6 opinions in the last 12 months.
The reviews on Canadian Tire Corporation Ltd. (CTC.A) reveal a divided perspective among experts. While some acknowledge the company's transformation and recent strong earnings—highlighting a 38% year-over-year increase in EPS—others express caution due to broader economic challenges facing consumers, who are shifting their spending toward necessities. The stock is seen as well diversified and is currently trading at approximately 15 times normalized earnings, indicating it is fairly valued. Analysts suggest a price target in the range of $150 to $200, with a recommendation to buy during tax-loss selling periods when the price might dip below $150. Nevertheless, experts often prefer competitors like Dollarama (DOL) or NWC, particularly due to their more defensive profiles and lower valuations compared to CTC.A.
This ranks almost dead centre in the middle of all the Canadian companies he looks at. The price has been dropping, so technically it ranks in the bottom 20% of his rankings. He would like to see an improvement in both rankings. Longer-term, this is a great company. If you are more into the value camp, you could start looking at this for a 2-3 year timeframe.
Their exposure to the economy has been better than the GDP numbers. There are concerns about their recent shift in management. Also have been pretty good on the digital side of things. They own some good brands, so there is diversification. Its really a question of exposure to the Canadian consumer, and he prefers the US consumer.
This has been the star of Canadian retailers, and has held up very well. It has done extremely well over the last number of years despite retail undergoing the biggest shift in technology in the way people shop. They have a new CEO, who he believes is going to take a longer-term focus and position them for going forward. It still looks a little expensive to him. If he saw it correct 10%-15% from here, he would be taking a really serious look at it.
He likes the name. Overall it is good. There is some weakness in the consumer, but in general it is one of the areas that has held up really well, in both Canada and the US. The old CEO becoming the new CEO is something that would be a good catalyst. With any retailer, the Internet is a huge force, and Amazon (AMZN-Q) pretty well owns it. A lot of retailers are suffering, but this is not one he would think was most problematic.
Trading at about 15X earnings, which is not too bad compared to a lot of other retailers, so from a value perspective it seems okay. Has never been able to wrap his head around the different types of companies they have, whether it is the sports type or the Canadian Tire brand itself. With the real estate, that has pushed the shares up a little. He likes it here, but just has not bought shares yet.
This is one of the areas he thinks people might rotate out of. They are continuing to execute well however. People are waiting for an acquisition of some sort. He hopes it is in Canada. It has been a great story from the beginning of time.