Opinions
Mohsin Bashir
Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce
CM-T
COMMENT
Jan 12, 2017
Stock price when the opinion was issued
You might be interested:
Make sure it stays above $86. A range of $5 is not going to break the bank ;) But $86 is where you might want to start trimming and looking at some of the underperforming banks such as TD. He can't imagine TD will stay in its current situation forever. This strategy will also add to your diversification. But be cautious selling, because it's on a nice upswing.
This type of stock is not going to drop from $91 to $50 on a single announcement, it's a lot more predictable than that.
Taking less on credit provisions than other banks. Positive: credit situation better than others. Negative: taking more risk and, if wrong, stock would be penalized. Canada-centric. Exposed to residential mortgages and commercial real estate in Canada; two iffy sectors, but doing better than expected. Good earnings and good asset management.
Don't sell. Trading more cheaply than RY. RY commands a premium price for a premium asset.
Used to have a habit of running into sharp objects, but CEO has turned this around. Warrants consideration. Great domestic personal and commercial business, capital markets, and wealth management. Modest presence in US, and has stayed out of trouble there.
If you already own NA and RY, consider TD or BMO before this one. But if you're going to add 2 more banks to your portfolio, no quarrels with adding this one.
Premium contentWe've already recommended National Bank, so let's look at the second-cheapest bank, CIBC, with its 11.2.x PE and EPS growth over five years of 5.39%, better than RY's 5.16%. Commerce has beaten its last four quarters with room to spare, and pays a safe dividend of 4.49%. Its EPS growth is beating the sector, and its most recent EPS was 17.89% higher than a year ago. CIBC's margins outpace the sector. Unlike TD, CIBC has a small presence south of the border. Because of that, a lot of its business lies in Canada—residential mortgages and commercial business—which will slow down if the economy does. That would explain why the street has assigned CIBC a lower future PE of 11.09x. That said, CIBC offers a safe, generous dividend with reasonable room to grow, certainly better than TD.
They were downgraded because of worries in the housing markets. The risks are that they are predominantly the Canadian housing lender and winning market share from peers. They have reinvented themselves. There are also concerns about the Canadian housing market. Multiples for all the Canadian banks are low in absolute terms, but high is historical terms. They might grow in terms of dividend growth, but may have headwinds that their peers who are in the US don’t have as much.