NYSE:CAT

Caterpillar (CAT)

1,057.01
+62.56 (6.29%)
as of Jun 25, 2026, 8:00:00 pm Market Open.
181 watching
0
Investor Insights
star iconJun 25, 2026, 12:00 am

This summary was created by AI, based on 31 opinions in the last 12 months.

Caterpillar (CAT) has been a popular choice among experts, primarily due to its robust earnings growth and significant backlog of orders, reportedly exceeding $60 billion. While many express optimism regarding its potential in the infrastructure and data center segments driven by trends like AI and energy demand, concerns about its current P/E ratio, which has risen considerably to 32-36x, have led some to take profits or warn against buying at this level. The stock has seen hefty appreciation in 2023, with reports of increases around 140% for some investors, indicating both excitement and caution about its overheated status. Overall, CAT is viewed as a strong play on global infrastructure but analysts suggest caution regarding its valuation and the cyclical nature of the industrial sector.

consensus icon
Consensus
Positive
valuation icon
Valuation
Overvalued
review icon
Similar
Deere,DE
BUY

Pays a good 3.5% yield with a 10x PE, which are likely depressed by the global slowdown and the trade war, but the slowdown will turn. Buy this if you have a 3-5-year horizon. Governments need to start spending on infrastructure to get economies going. Also look at CMI-N.

DON'T BUY
A cyclical stock whose customers are into mining and forestry. Not the best time to be entering into this space.
DON'T BUY
It's under heavy pressure from an overhang from the resources slump and, before, the steel tarffis. There are better opportunities elsewhere.
PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick May 24/18, Down 20%) This is a highly cyclical name. Looking at slowing global growth and he prefers more defensive names. This is an industrial name and prefers Waste Management in this space. He expects CAT just to move sideways.
BUY
Call option? CAT should rally if the China-US trade deal is signed. If you sell a call option on CAT, go 5-8% out. A deal is only partially priced in now.
WATCH

He's watching it. On their conference call Q1 there was a major misunderstanding about the guidance they gave; no, they haven't hit their peak for the year. Rather they reached the high point on their margin percentage. The street reacted negatively and sold. It was astonishing. A fine company, but he's not sure this is the best company in this space and there's a lot of competition here.

DON'T BUY

A big name but has a lot of debt. Big US company. A perfect target for tariffs. Trades at reach valuations. He would be cautious.

TOP PICK

Just bought it this month. The global economy is accelerating, and sales are doing well. There is a recovery in commodity prices and that is helping them. Trading at 14 times earnings with a 20% growth rate. (Analysts’ price target is $172.32)

TOP PICK

Just bought it this month. The global economy is accelerating, and sales are doing well. There is a recovery in commodity prices and that is helping them. Trading at 14 times earnings with a 20% growth rate. (Analysts’ price target is $172.32)

PAST TOP PICK

(A Top Pick Feb 13’17, Down 64.73%) He thought it had down legs. Global growth was greater than expected. They restructured so much that their earnings grew. It is still a cyclical industry. He could see being short of this stock.

BUY

AAPL-Q vs. CAT-N. CAT-N is machinery and has been a hero. They both really pulled back. CAT-N had a 22% earnings beat last quarter. AAPL-Q is really the iPhone X or 10 story. They missed on units. It is not a lost leader but the concept applies. This will be used like the iPad with augmented reality. You are in a very expensive period of time – an air pocket. AAPL-Q is a great company, however.

PAST TOP PICK

(A Top Pick Nov 16/16. Down 52%.) *Short* At the time, this was trading at over 30 times earnings, with basically 3 years of down earnings. It was trading at a ridiculously high multiple. They missed on the past 5 quarters, and the stock had run up on the idea that Donald Trump was going to build the wall using thousands of Caterpillar tractors. He underestimated the global recovery, which helped sales. On top of that, they operationally improved their margins to such a degree that earnings recovery has grown through the estimates in the last three quarters. Has shorted again recently because, although a good story, it is trading at 25X what he thinks will be their peak earnings.

COMMENT

This was basically left for dead and everybody was very negative on it. It hit a low in late January 2016, and has rebounded nicely. It was a long, long decline for the better part of 2 years, and then finally started to turn around, and it is breaking out again. This is its first break-out in 6 years. This is probably a pretty positive thing for everybody in the world, because it means very, very hard-core resources and commodities are getting moved around.

TOP PICK

It has done well through a difficult period. 80% of the revenue from that sector was just replacement parts. This equipment wears out and has to be replaced and maintained. It has the fastest earnings revisions of any S&P company. (Analysts’ target: $125.00).

PAST TOP PICK

(A Top Pick June 13/16. Down 57%.) *Short* He closed out the Short on November 15. Overall, they have done really well, and certainly defied many people who thought a Short was a good idea.

Showing 106 to 120 of 289 entries