TSE:XID

iShares CNX Nifty India (XID.TO)

41.99
+0.02 (0.05%)
as of Jun 10, 2026, 6:57:36 pm Market Open.
40 watching
0
Investor Insights
star iconJun 9, 2026, 12:00 am

This summary was created by AI, based on 3 opinions in the last 12 months.

The iShares CNX Nifty India ETF (XID-T) comes highly regarded as a prominent choice for Canadian investors looking to gain exposure to India, highlighting its notable status as the top ETF in Canadian dollars for the region. Despite its popularity, concerns regarding its higher management expense ratio (MER) of 1% were voiced, leading some experts to prefer alternatives like ZID due to lower fees and better diversification. The potential for significant growth in India, especially given its youthful population and ongoing infrastructure initiatives, adds an optimistic outlook to the investment case for XID. However, experts recommend considering a broader approach to emerging markets (EMs), suggesting that an overall EM ETF like ZEM may also be a beneficial investment strategy amidst expectations of a weakening USD supporting EM currencies and stock markets as a whole.

consensus icon
Consensus
Mixed
valuation icon
Valuation
Fair Value
review icon
Similar
ZIL,DZIL
DON'T BUY
ETF in Canadian $$ for India?

Probably one of the larger ones out there. MER is a bit up there at 99 bps. 

He'd rather approach the EMs as a whole, rather than just an individual country -- there's a high propensity for volatility and returns are dispersed. Look at ZEM.

WEAK BUY
XID vs. ZID

Likes the idea of India, as more than half its population is under the age of 30. If they ever get their infrastructure efforts in gear, then they can grow their economy a whole lot faster than NA. The opportunity is definitely there. 

First thing to look at are the holdings. XID is "an index of an index", which is the iShares India 50. With ZID, you get the actual companies. Next thing to look at are the fees. MER of XID is 1%, for ZID it's 0.72%. So on his quick perusal, ZID is the better of the two -- it's cheaper, and you get better diversification.

BUY

Tons of ETFs in emerging markets, and one of the areas you should be focused on. If he could have a fourth Top Pick, this area is an exceptional place to be looking. EM's currencies and stock markets will do well with a weaker USD (a goal of the US administration).

PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Jul 24/23, Up 23%)

Excellent product, that will continue to hold. Very good performance of Indian economy. Would recommend a small portion to balance portfolio. Large tech advances in the Indian economy. Excellent compliment to North American equities. 

DON'T BUY

India has been an amazing growth story, attracting enormous interest. India ETFs in Canada and US tend to be more expensive. Legacy product from iShares, but expensive.

WEAK BUY

He has very little EM exposure. But compared to developed markets, EMs have gotten very cheap on valuation and price. Likes EMs, and India is one of the leaders in that space. This ETF has performed well, up 21% in past year.

Note that you can buy a similar ETF, INDA, in USD for a cheaper MER.

BUY

Good product to get exposure to India stock markets. Helps get emerging markets performance as well. Relatively safe product. Would recommend buying. 

TOP PICK

India surpassing China as most populous country. 
English speaking with Western influence.
Rebellion against China - will see investment from West.
Good for international exposure. 

TOP PICK
He had been suggesting China but he now suggests changing that to India. The median age there is 28. The rate of literacy is growing dramatically.
WAIT

VEE vs. XID VEE covers EM. XID: India has a young working population who speak English. India fits well into global commerce. If they build their infrastructure, India will do well. Problem is, everyone knows India's long-term story and already have high expectations. India has been underperforming the past year, so he wants to see India cheaper and offer better performance before stepping in. Wait. Look at SCIF for India small-caps For EM, focus on Asian EMs, so go with GMF-N instead of VEE.

STRONG BUY
He loves emerging markets and broad diversification, so he prefers VEE to XID. But also, India is an excellent country to invest with EM. India boasts a growing middle class and upwardly mobile workplace--he would bet big on India. However, don't bet the farm on any ETF, but rather 5-10%.
COMMENT

XID vs VEE (India vs. EM) VEE is Asia-ex Japan. It contains some major India stocks, plus Korea and China. With XID, you're making a country call. Do you know something about India that the world does not? He is not a country allocator. Take a look at Forstrong ETFs (https://www.forstrong.com/) who actively manage and you need that if you're so country-specific.

COMMENT
Similar to ZID. There used to be a difference, but he thinks not anymore. He likes India. Horrible bureaucracy there though. Made a lot of progress. Huge companies are there. Should do more homework on this. One of the things about including EM in portfolios is that you have to be careful not to overweight. He is conservative with EMs.
COMMENT

XID-T vs. ZID-T. A Difference in Tax Treatment? With a Canadian based ETF holding US ETFs subject to US withholding tax you can get double withholdings. He suggests asking the ETF provider what the tax consequences are for holding their funds in your Canadian account.

PAST TOP PICK

(A Top Pick May 2/16. Up 38%.) A great way to get access to the growing middle class in India.

Showing 1 to 15 of 34 entries

iShares CNX Nifty India (XID.TO) Frequently Asked Questions

What is iShares CNX Nifty India stock symbol?

iShares CNX Nifty India is a Canadian stock, trading under the symbol XID.TO (previously XID-T on Stockchase) on the Toronto Stock Exchange (XID-CT). It is usually referred to as TSX:XID or XID.TO

Is iShares CNX Nifty India a buy or a sell?

In the last year, 3 stock analysts published opinions about XID.TO (previously XID-T on Stockchase). 2 analysts recommended to BUY the stock. 1 analyst recommended to SELL the stock. The latest stock analyst recommendation is PAST TOP PICK. Read the latest stock experts' ratings for iShares CNX Nifty India.

Is iShares CNX Nifty India a good investment or a top pick?

iShares CNX Nifty India was recommended as a Top Pick by John DeGoey on 2017-06-08. Read the latest stock experts ratings for iShares CNX Nifty India.

Why is iShares CNX Nifty India stock dropping?

Earnings reports or recent company news can cause the stock price to drop. Read stock experts' recommendations for help on deciding if you should buy, sell or hold the stock.

Is iShares CNX Nifty India worth watching?

3 stock analysts on Stockchase covered iShares CNX Nifty India in the last year. It is a trending stock that is worth watching.

What is iShares CNX Nifty India stock price?

On 2026-06-10, iShares CNX Nifty India (XID.TO) stock closed at a price of $41.99.

Star iconStar iconStar iconStar half iconStar empty icon
3.7(3)
Based on 3 expert opinions: 2 buy 0 hold 1 sell