Stockchase Opinions

Colin CieszynskiToyotaTMDON'T BUYJun 20, 2024

Auto sector mixed. Supply issues. Peaked in March, now lower highs and lows. Downward trend suggests traders selling the rallies. Just because a group moves in a certain direction, doesn't mean everything does at the same time.

$194.25

Stock price when the opinion was issued

Automotive
It's the ideal tool to help you make quicker, more informed decisions for managing and tracking your investments.

You might be interested:

DON'T BUY

He doesn't own auto stocks. Its brilliance was in staying away from EVs, and focusing on hybrids. Probably most rock-solid of all the auto makers. Too capital-intensive for him. Sensitive to consumer spending.

HOLD

Tariff ambiguity is going to be there for the foreseeable future. Tariffs will bring more assembly infrastructure into the US. Decent industrial company. Automakers as a whole are not attractive businesses, but this name is arguably the best of the bunch.

Subaru is actually far cheaper, and tapped into the Toyota supply chain. (Toyota owns 10% of Subaru.)

BUY

Business performing well. Has taken a measured approach to EV adoption. Slowly getting into EV sales, but doing so strategically. Excellent cars that last a long time. Brand name very strong in North America. 

DON'T BUY

Made its bed on hybrids vs. EVs. Who knows where the technology will be 10 years from now? Car companies are very capital intensive, so earnings get badly impacted in a slowdown. Not great value. He owns RACE.

BUY

Didn't rush to build EVs the way others did, and this will help in the long run. In general, EVs are not selling well, inventories are building up, and infrastructure isn't yet there. Hybrid option has the most mileage longevity, and Toyota seems to be going that route, which is the most prudent approach. Great cars, huge company. Safe for a 3-5 year hold.

BUY
TM vs. GM vs. TSLA

Depends on your risk tolerance. He's been looking at GM recently, but hasn't taken any action. Really good recent quarter, will be pressure on financing side of the business. Targets are pretty optimistic. TM is a safer bet for the next year or so; it's a giant company with improving profits, uncertainty on EV strategy is not a short-term game-changer. TSLA is his favourite EV play in the auto-making space. TSLA has already won the EV race, especially as to vertical integration.

HOLD
We are seeing some green shoots in auto dealers over the last few weeks. TM-N offers both Gas and Electric vehicles. For auto sales you have to understand 2021 – how many layoffs are permanent. He thinks auto sales will continue to decrease over the next two to three years. More auto companies may be more open to mergers in the next 5 years. TM-N is in the top half of auto names. He has owned it before in his dividend portfolio.
BUY
Global auto makers are behaving better right now and the Japanese market is improving. He would support an investor buying here.
DON'T BUY
They make great cars. He does not like the space. With the exception of China, auto sales have been flat for 20 years. There will be some winners but it is too early to speculate on which will be the winners. If you have to be in this sector, it is a good car maker.
DON'T BUY
Fuel cells for cars Fuel cells have never been economical for carmakers, though they have been around for 30+ years. Toyota and other carmakers are still dabbling with it, because batteries on the e-car side are reaching their limits. Customers demand range. Toyota and the car sector are slumping globally--the economy is slow.
DON'T BUY

He used to own a lot of Ford and GM. Auto sales have not really increased since the 1990s. Now with the disruptive forces of Uber and Lyft, the space is that much more challenging. Transport is changing. Owning a car is not always part of the assets one owns anymore.

WAIT
Auto plays are on the backs of consumers, and we're late in the cycle. It's getting tough for people to afford things. Dividend is only 5.9%, and that's average. Likes to see it 6-7-8%, because that creates more compounded income. If he was going to choose, this might not be a bad idea.
BUY
High on his list if he were to buy a car company. Well-capitalized with less debt than most peers. Also has tremendous market share. Trades at 11x earnings pays a 3% dividend. Great for conservative investors. This has outperformed the global car industry for decades.
DON'T BUY
He thinks the US economy is in a better shape than the Canadian. As you raise interest rates your currency gets stronger so he thinks the US$ will strengthen and US equities will strengthen. You need to be cautious with AUTOs. We are seeing a slowdown. Electrification and hybrid vehicles present uncertainty. He does not know where this company stands with electric vehicles.