Josef SchachterCanadian Natural RsrcsCNQ.TOCOMMENTDec 05, 2012

He sold some of it in the first run-up. You can hold but he would sell if oil still goes up - not sustainable at these levels. If oil goes down he would buy more. It is one of the best companies and is very good at acquiring other companies. It has increased its dividend and free cash flow.

More focused on gas. Over time, O&G sector should continue to improve. GOC has announced more focus on major projects in Canada, most likely involving another LNG facility to facilitate getting our gas to other markets. That would help this name.

Hasn't been adding recently, as other stocks in the sector look more interesting. Core, dominant player. Low-cost, long-life assets. With the war in Iran, international investors are looking at Canada and its energy again.

For him, SHEL purchase of ARX was a turning point. Going to see more of that.

When asked to compare these four large companies if the price of oil drops, he felt that CNQ is a phenomenal company that's hard to beat. Suncor has been a turnaround story for the past two years. The quarterly reports have been much better. Rich Kruger is moving on to be the Executive Chair. If the price of oil does drop Imperial might be the best defensive play.
Editor's Note; For Cenovus, please refer to his previous answer.

Yes, he'd put new $$ in today. Buying stocks at 52-week highs isn't necessarily bad for your wealth (you'll actually do better than consistently buying at 52-week lows). Possible (but he can't say for sure) to retrace to mid-$50s if Iran war were to end.

On normalized oil prices, high single-digit FCF yield. Low-cost operator, decent production growth, strong balance sheet. Excellent capital allocation.

One of the best in Canadian energy. It continues to do well. Fine valuation and it's stable. A great one.

He targets $50-60 oil over the next decade. He's bullish for an oil trade, but is very concerned oil stocks will fall back down to historic norms.

Is one of the better natural gas plays. 

Oil reserves in a safe haven. Well run. If peace breaks out in the Middle East, all the energy names could retrace somewhat; if conflict escalates, then oil will run and you should take profits along the way. 

If you're looking at a 3-10 year investment, by all means buy some energy here. But if you're looking for a 3-6 month trade, you have to be careful with these politically charged components of the market.

He can't tell you where the price of oil is going. He does know that demand continues to increase. One of the best capital allocators in the O&G space. Decades and decades of reserves. Increased dividend for 25-26 consecutive years.

For a generalist, long-term investor, trust the management of the quality leader. When oil turns down, this name will hold up better. If there was a pullback for no good reason, he'd buy more. Be patient and wait for your opportunity.

A conservative and integrated choice in the space.

His go-to name in the energy space. The oilsands operators gush cash (and will for a long time), which gives them lots of options. Income and growth. Valuation has kept him from adding right now.

The stock has done very well and it pays a 3.4% dividend. Benefits from the higher oil price. Is her top choice in Canadian oil.

The question was on his preference between Suncor and CNQ. He would side with Suncor since it has more upside and CNQ's price is approaching fair value. Suncor has underperformed over the past week with the CEO stepping down. He had guided the company to a major turn-around. If the next CEO can continue to run the company as well as it has been running then he sees a 40% upside two years out.

Her favourite in the space. Premier assets. Will benefit from natural gas prices should they ever recover. Management has never cut the dividend, no matter the environment for oil.