Visa Inc.VTOP PICKFeb 01, 2024Stock price when the opinion was issued
As of Sep 25, 2026. Market Open.
You'd have to go back a very long time to find his firm holding MA. Owned V for a long time, mainly on the valuation differential. MA has always been 4-6 multiple points higher. Visa is better value. Likes the space.
V might be stronger on the debit card side, which is growing at a faster rate than the credit side. Likes management. PE in the 20s, a discount to normalized multiples. Consistent, predictable. Earnings continue to do well. Nice hedge to a lot of companies that are in the news.
Visa and Mastercard have been treading water the past year because the market has been fixated on AI, but that money has been rotating out of AI into places like credit cards. The two companies have some of the best business models, big moats and trading at attractive PEs, though neither are at decades-long low PEs. Visa's layoff of 7% of workforce is good for the stock. Probably AI is making Visa more productive.
Mastercard and Visa have been weak because cash-to-card conversion has historically been the easiest thing for them to do but is now over. Value-added services are instead driving more growth. Agentic AI traffic is about to go parabolic, so can the cards play the role of authentication layer? He thinks so, and they should. Stablecoins and peer-to-peer transactions are not big deals, not major threats.
In fact, Visa's share has risen from 52.8% in 2007 to 61% in 2022 (based on transaction volume). Mastercard holds 25.5%, down from 28.2% in that period, while AmEx has slipped from 15.6% to 11.3%. AmEx caters to the business class and wealthier clientele. When they spend, AmEx rallies, but if they spend less, then AmEx falters. That sums up AmEx in the past year, and it's currently enjoying the best momentum. If you expect this trend to continue, then buy AmEx. If you want less volatility, an established brand and consistent earnings, then go with Visa.