
(A Top Pick Dec 10/14. Up 13.8%.) Chart shows it has had a pretty rocky road. It was 3X as high as where it is now. A company that has executed fairly well, but needs to prove their numbers out. A Short Seller’s report came out, but they were able to refute all his points. Then they had an auditor change, which really dragged their feet in getting the financials done, so they were late with their accounting. If you don’t own this, you certainly want to watch it. Once the accounting issue is finalized that will be the 1st step. The 2nd will be their next quarter of earnings to make sure they meet expectations that management has put out.
He was buying this because of a profound overreaction to a Short report that came out. He sold after he had about a 33% run when the company came out with an announcement that they had hired a fairly respected attorney who discredited the report. This is a name he might revisit early next year. He doesn’t like the excess of volatility.
He has not seen too many instances of companies being successful in this kind of law suit. They really put the numbers up and hit the guidance they said they would hit. They have a new auditor, who has some issues with converting some things from IFRS over to GAAP. Once that is cleared up and if they hit their Q4 numbers, then the stock will regain some of the lost ground.
In healthcare, you have had Short Sell reports coming after a variety of the Canadian names. The company came out today to try to dispel those rumors and the myth about what was being put out there, and the stock rallied pretty sharply with a 20% gain on the day. He thinks the stock will recover. (See Top Picks.)
An anonymous blogger came out with an 8 page report, 95% of which is probably containing massive fallacies, incorrect statements and bad math. Because of Valeant (VRX-T), sentiment towards healthcare stocks is dismal. The new CEO owns a boatload of shares. Stock was down another 15% today on the announcement of a class-action lawsuit from some ambulance chasers in the US. The challenge is, if you lose your market multiple, you are kind of pooched if you don’t have a good business. This company thinks they can grow organically next year by 20%. If you believe, anywhere remotely close to their production for EBITDA next year, it is trading around 4-4.5 times to EBITDA. They have organic growth. He bought some today.
They are going to try to go after these guys that wrote this screed. Evidently there is a Toronto-based hedge fund that is implicated. He thinks they are going to put up good earnings shortly, and eventually people will ignore the stuff. He hopes the OSC will do its job; he is not waiting for the Calvary. At the end of the day, this company has great earnings. If their stock doesn’t start moving, they have enough cash that they can just start buying it back.
This was taken down 25% on Friday on a bearish seeking Alpha Post, written by a Short seller. They basically rehashed a bunch of old information about the company. The company has come out and said there was nothing going on and there were no material changes. The post created some inaccuracies. Stock was up more than 300% and is a relatively highly traded retail company, and was really ripe for a Short attack. The moral is, “Don’t panic on a long weekend.”. He has been a bit cautious on this company.
The bigger trend on the stock is down. There is some appearance of bottoming taking place. The lows were slightly lower. At this point he probably wouldn’t touch this. He would like to see it break the sideways movement and break out at around $6, and start to move up.