Stock price when the opinion was issued
The consensus earnings estimate in the next 12 months is minus $0.47. Up until recently, they have been paying out dividends of $0.39, so clearly something didn’t fit, so the dividend had to go. Not a terribly strong balance sheet. If it gets down to $1.84, he would probably take a swing at this one, but with his heart in his hand.
When you look at the earnings forecast for the coming year, minus 37%, even the dividend they are paying now doesn’t cover what they are paying out. What concerns him is the long run balance sheet trend back to 2011, which is in a downward slope. It doesn’t have a particularly robust balance sheet and is paying out too much in dividends and selling at BV right now.
He does not like it. They cancelled their dividend. You expect one from a utility. The share price is down about 10% this year. Things are improving, but he does not recommend it.