Stockchase Opinions

Don VialouxiShares S&P/TSX 60 Index ETFXIU.TOCOMMENTFeb 12, 2014

Does seasonality apply to an index such as TSX 60? Seasonality in Canadian markets is very pronounced. The best period to own the TSX Composite is from October 28th each year, right through until May 5th each year. Chart is showing a strong upper trend and we are getting very close to breaking through to new highs. The TSX Composite is going to be the 1st major equity index in the world to move to a new high and it could do this in the next couple of days. Historically, the best time to own the Canadian market relative to the US market is from the middle of December right through until the middle of March. That is the middle of RRSP contribution time, which is one of the reasons Canadian markets tend to outperform US markets at that time.

$20.09

Stock price when the opinion was issued

$51.18

As of Jun 11, 2026. Market Open.

investment companiesfunds
It's the ideal tool to help you make quicker, more informed decisions for managing and tracking your investments.

You might be interested:

BUY

Great long-term holding and a way to defer taxable gains.

COMMENT
XIU vs. XIC

Fellow travellers -- tend to go in the same direction most of the time. The TSX 60 (XIU) is about 80% of the weight of the index. 

So you have to ask yourself what you want to do about the other 20%? It's a combination of small- and mid-caps and junior resource stocks. You can get really good returns out of that piece, but it's also a lot more risk. A lot more volatile. 

How much return are you seeking? How much risk and volatility can you live with? What are you comfortable with? What are your priorities as an investor? Last year, resources did really well. But you'll have years where they just get hammered and the TSX 60 outperforms the composite.

BUY
ETF suggestion for the broad Canadian market?

XIU is just the Canadian market. Lots of energy, lots of banking, some industrials and materials. Canadian market's outperforming the US market and has been for 18 months. Who would have guessed at the beginning of the year? Once that starts, it usually goes on to behave that way for 7-9 years at a time. 

Important big picture:  international markets, which include Canada, are in a great spot.

BUY

Great way to get exposure to Canadian equities. Has performed well the past 5 years. Would recommend buying as a way to get exposure to Canadian economy. 

BUY

Oldest ETF in the world (launched in the 1990s). Cheaper ETF's but overall, a great product. Over the long term, good product. 

BUY

Excellent growth option. Lots of tech, consumer and healthcare stocks. Would recommend buying for the long term. 

BUY ON WEAKNESS

Banks have down poorly this which has limited the TSX, though oil has gone up. You need the financials to do well for XIU to do well. But in the long run, this will outperform in coming years.

Unspecified

It holds a basket of large cap Canadian names and he likes it for the energy and banks holdings. The TSX 60 is not as far ahead as its counterparts in the U.S.

HOLD

Well know ETF with ~3.4% dividend yield.
Canadian banks, utilities and infrastructure included.
Good ETF, but prefers XEI.

BUY
Allan Tong’s Discover Picks XIU stock charges only a 0.18% MER but pays a 3.02% dividend yield. Averaging 3,000,000 shares a day, XIU is fairly liquid, over six times more than, say, XIC-T. The biggest holding here is Shopify which has been quietly making a comeback, followed by Royal and TD, the country’s biggest banks. Enbridge, CN, BAM and the other banks are also major holdings and well-regarded by investors. XIU is a cautious trade, one that an investor can enter and exit at a profit. Read 3 Defensive Stocks to Catch the Rebound for our full analysis.
BUY
XIU vs. XIC Correlations and holdings are quite similar. XIC is more diversified, with about 240 holdings. XIC has a 6 bps MER, while XIU is 18 bps. Performance has been very similar. XIU has a bigger weighting in banks, about 28%. XIC has about 23% in banks. Not much diversification if you own both. Also look at XEI, a high dividend ETF, geared towards a higher yield.
COMMENT

XIU has a slightly higher MER. HXT does not distribute the income but is capitalized into the portfolio holdings. It makes it a capital gain than dividend income. The redemption cost is also a factor. Would prefer HXT all things considered.

BUY

An ETF to buy? There are so many ETFs, so it depends what you're looking for. XIU offers growth and income for retirees. This is a core holding for any investors. There's also a BMO utilities ETF offering a yield and upside. Also, a Canadian bank ETF from any vendor will give you income and growth, like ZWB-T. An ETF reduces volatility vs. owning individual stocks.

PARTIAL BUY
As easy as it gets for passive investment. Broad-based exposure to the Canadian market. Financials, tiny bit of energy, lifecos, pipelines. If you expect returns over time of 6-7%, it's a good holding. Income stream is pretty solid. Markets are a bit overbought right now, so don't go full bolt right now. Instead, dollar cost average in.
COMMENT

HXT-T vs. XIU-T. They have basically identical holding but one pays a dividend so has different tax treatment. He is indifferent. In a TFSA, there is no reason to not to use the XIU-T.