Stock price when the opinion was issued
ATH vs HSE vs MEG? The clear stand out is MEG, who is 55% hedged at $59 oil prices. ATH has a high cost project with Hangingstone and is burning cash, although they have enough liquidity for the next 9 months. He would never own HSE, because of their ESG issues. All bets are off for all of them if $25 oil prices remain in 2021.
Stock vs. Stock. HSE-T vs. SU-T. There is probably more value in HSE-T over SU-T. HSE-T does not have the retail division to the extent that SU-T does. HSE-T is more oversold that SU-T.