Opinions
Brian Madden
Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce
CM-T
DON'T BUY
Sep 28, 2023
Stock price when the opinion was issued
You might be interested:
Premium contentWe've already recommended National Bank, so let's look at the second-cheapest bank, CIBC, with its 11.2.x PE and EPS growth over five years of 5.39%, better than RY's 5.16%. Commerce has beaten its last four quarters with room to spare, and pays a safe dividend of 4.49%. Its EPS growth is beating the sector, and its most recent EPS was 17.89% higher than a year ago. CIBC's margins outpace the sector. Unlike TD, CIBC has a small presence south of the border. Because of that, a lot of its business lies in Canada—residential mortgages and commercial business—which will slow down if the economy does. That would explain why the street has assigned CIBC a lower future PE of 11.09x. That said, CIBC offers a safe, generous dividend with reasonable room to grow, certainly better than TD.
Owns it in his firm's dividend model. Doesn't expect a stock split, as banks have abandoned the old rule of thumb to split once stock reaches $100.
We now have an understanding that tariffs will be 35%, which will cause some havoc importing our goods into the US. But can Mark Carney grow Canada by continuing to reduce barriers and by seeing some growth between provinces? If yes, then banks in general are primed to do quite well going forward. They'll be supplying the funding for companies, infrastructure, etc.
The chart shows a V-shaped recovery since April's tariff worries. In Canada, interest rates have been cut aggressively, so the Canadian banks have skated through. Wealth management divisions are strong. Loan loss provisions are down. NA and RY are the best, but CM and BMO are reporting much better earnings, which catches his attention.
All of the interest sensitives have been under pressure the last couple of months with rates rising.
He favours TD. Tightly regulated oligopoly, and a levered play on the growth of the Canadian, and increasingly US, economy. Surplus of excess capital. 10x earnings. Dominant personal and commercial banking franchise. Good-sized banking presence in the US. Shares are at a discount to average. Close to 5% yield, growing at 8% compound over 10 years.
Valuation and yield of SLF are similar to TD. But TD's competitive position in its industry is more advantageous than SLF.
Compared to CM, TD is more of a scale player with a stronger franchise on both sides of the border on its core banking business.