NYSE:CAT

Caterpillar (CAT)

1,057.01
+62.56 (6.29%)
as of Jun 25, 2026, 8:00:00 pm Market Open.
181 watching
0
Investor Insights
star iconJun 25, 2026, 12:00 am

This summary was created by AI, based on 31 opinions in the last 12 months.

Caterpillar (CAT) has been a popular choice among experts, primarily due to its robust earnings growth and significant backlog of orders, reportedly exceeding $60 billion. While many express optimism regarding its potential in the infrastructure and data center segments driven by trends like AI and energy demand, concerns about its current P/E ratio, which has risen considerably to 32-36x, have led some to take profits or warn against buying at this level. The stock has seen hefty appreciation in 2023, with reports of increases around 140% for some investors, indicating both excitement and caution about its overheated status. Overall, CAT is viewed as a strong play on global infrastructure but analysts suggest caution regarding its valuation and the cyclical nature of the industrial sector.

consensus icon
Consensus
Positive
valuation icon
Valuation
Overvalued
review icon
Similar
Deere,DE
BUY

It reports Tuesday. He expects a good quarter as CAT rides the wave of infrastructure spending and re-shoring.

BUY

He bought more CAT. It's a stealthy play in the data centre space where CAT does the heavy construction. This trades at only 17x PE, a 25% discount to John Deere, historically wide. Pays a 2% dividend and has lots of free cash flow.

BUY

Owns it for the data centre build, which is seeing huge demand.

WATCH

They report Wednesday. Benefits from Joe Biden's infrastructure bill and has plenty of projects to build ahead.

DON'T BUY

The former CEO was good, but no longer running the company. However, shares are not expensive now, -18% this year. That said, it's not the time to buy this (could fall further).

RISKY

Rough go recently. About 50% of production is domestic to the US. 35% of its business is recurring service revenue, encouraging. Questions around international business. If recession and tariffs are permanent, expect trouble. 

If those clouds dissipate, this could be a good entry point. US administration has changed, but infrastructure renewal needs remain strong. What you could do is buy this, but barbell it with more defensive areas such as telcos, utilities, consumer staples.

WAIT

Wait until the CEO speaks at the next quarter, given the very uncertain macro environment.

HOLD
Trevor Rose’s Insights - Trevor’s most-liked answers from 5i Research

CAT is $165B market cap, 17X earnings, 1.62% yield, 6.96% five year dividend growth, down 4% YTD, debt/cash flow about 3X, forward growth about 10%. DE is $135B, 25X earnings, 1.30% yield, 14.68% dividend growth, 5X debt/cash flow, forward growth 15%. We would consider both HOLDS today. While good companies, they will be vulnerable in a global economic decline, as both have been in prior cycles. Automation/AI will help margins, but this will take some time to show up in the numbers. Mining expansions (CAT) and weak spending (DE) will likely mean less-than-robust growth and/or weak sentiment for a period of time. 
Unlock Premium - Try 5i Free

WATCH

It reports Thursday, but decide after you hear the conference call so you can learn their future. CAT is no longer cyclical, but a secular grower due to a CEO pushing CAT into consistent end markets.

TOP PICK
All-time high late September.

Higher highs so far, and we're testing the last low. Overall trend is good. He's still buying, has done 2 legs of 2% each so far. Yield is 1.5%.

Note that if the market turns down in a big way this will be one of its victims, as industrials will be one of the first to fall. 

(Analysts’ price target is $397.81)
TOP PICK

Active in over 190 countries. Infrastructure spending should increase due to new US administration. Tax cuts, deregulation, and trade policies should also help. Stimulus in China might be of benefit, as might Trump's threats to DE. Yield is 1.4%.

Now has broken above previous resistance. Pretty good trend of higher highs and higher lows since late 2022.

(Analysts’ price target is $373.45)
DON'T BUY

They report Wednesday. People want to know about their inventory. They will talk about the data centre. The company is doing well. Is up $60 from September lows. It's run too much. He likes it though.

DON'T BUY

He sold this before. This is expensive and is overvalued.

BUY

Likes it. Trading right at 200-day MA, so it's corrected down to an interesting level. 15x forward PE, growth rate is high single digits to low doubles.

China's always in the back of his mind, as it's such a big economy and affects so many different companies. Revenue from China is 18%, North America 52%, and Europe 20%. His base case for NA remains a soft landing, no recession.

SELL

CAT was a core holding until today's economic data showing a weaker than expected job market, adding to other weak data. So, he sold CAT. The economy is slowing. Also, he expects tech to lead the market for the coming 2-3 years.

Showing 31 to 45 of 289 entries