Stockchase Opinions

Larry Berman CFA, CMT, CTAHBP NYMEX Nat'l Gas Bull+HNU.TODON'T BUYSep 14, 2020

It is a leveraged natural gas ETF. It could be a good trade if you are well-versed in it, but you should not hold it long term at all. It is a tool for short term speculation.
$12.70

Stock price when the opinion was issued

$11.40

As of May 28, 2026. Market Open.

E.T.F.'s
It's the ideal tool to help you make quicker, more informed decisions for managing and tracking your investments.

You might be interested:

DON'T BUY

Double exposure to the natural gas market. Canadian and US stocks, in general, have a volatility of about 15%. The volatility of nat gas is in the range of 80%. So this one is a wild monster to deal with.

He's actually a bit bearish on energy because of the stated intention of the US government to pump oil and nat gas to lubricate the economy and economic growth. More production will hamper price increases. Secular pricing will be lower, spikes will only be cyclical.

The other side is that we have lots of AI power demand. Longer term, we could maybe see so much demand that prices get up off the floor.

DON'T BUY

He's not a commodity expert. PKI has leverage so it's volatile. You must be confident that the underlying commodity will move up. He's never seen anyone make money in this sector. You'd have to constantly watch oil prices to hold this.

TRADE

You only want to use this as a short-term vehicle for a seasonal trade. Not a buy-and-hold.

Disclosure:  He works for Global X (formerly Horizons).

DON'T BUY

It's leveraged. Don't buy it.

RISKY

Complicated product that are not meant for average investor. Must be watched daily. Not a linear response to natural gas prices. Would not recommend for the long term investor. High volatility. 

DON'T BUY
More of a short-term trading instrument. Definitely don't just park money in it, money gets lost in it every time there's a move. Instead, play via a TOU or even some of the US pure-play nat gas producers.
HOLD
Levered product is tricky and risky. Hard to predict future price of natural gas. Is a good short term trading product.
PARTIAL BUY
Leverage play for natural gas. Clearly getting a breakout in the short term. Thinks oil is capped out and natural gas should trade relative to oil. Can see front month natural gas contracts going for $5. Forward pricing looks like there is room into next year to move further up. An okay way to do it if you can handle leverage. Not for a long term buy and hold.
DON'T BUY
As the price natural gas rises The only problem is that HNU is leveraged. He doesn't like anything that is leveraged.
DON'T BUY
Over long periods of gas, there will be a natural decay in net asset value. Short term trading could pay off. Buy high and sell low. Natural gases are doing well right now, but he would prefer to play it through ETFs and equity exposure. Natural gas is a relative winner in the next few years. There has been significant under investments.
DON'T BUY

A Levearge ETF. He advised to steer clear of these kinds of investment. They are trading vehicles the are intended to be watched daily. D

DON'T BUY

A double leverage natural gas ETF. He would not hold for the long term. Go for HNY-T as you lose 3-5% per month based on losses in the nature of the futures contracts in the leveraged ETF. He also likes the Junior Natural Gas ETF ZJN-T for longer term.

COMMENT

The problem with playing these leveraged products is that it is basically a gamble. You are anticipating a short-term move, and in terms of the double leveraged Bull, you are hoping that is going to be positive. This is really a gambling tool, and not something he would like to play. Natural gas has been struggling at its 200-day moving average and is starting to curl lower. The builds in inventory levels over recent weeks have been higher than average. Going forward, we are looking at moderate temperatures in the US, so it doesn’t present that bullish backdrop for a near term rise.

COMMENT

Continue to Short this? Natural gas prices are probably coming down over the next couple of years. If this is a levered play, you want to be very, very careful. The way they do these things is that they roll them on a futures contract, and then have to keep buying the expiry. If you want to play natural gas, be very careful of the underlying structure that you are looking at.