Stockchase Opinions

Andy Nasr Granite REIT GRT.UN-T COMMENT Oct 19, 2017

There was a strategic review by management for potentially selling the company, but nothing came of that. There was some turnover with the CEO. The big issue is when it initially came to the market, it had very significant exposure to Magna (MG-T), which was their largest tenant. However, it had a pristine balance sheet. When you think of the Debt to Growth Book Value, it had approximately 25%, and the theory was that if they increased the leverage and took that Debt to Growth Book Value to 40%, they would have $1 billion to play with, diversify tenant exposure, make acquisitions. However they haven’t done any of that. That is unfortunate, because real estate prices have gone up significantly. It pays a decent dividend of 5%. His concern is that you really do need the leadership in there.

$50.560

Stock price when the opinion was issued

property mngmnt investment
It's the ideal tool to help you make quicker, more informed decisions for managing and tracking your investments.

You might be interested:

WEAK BUY

Benefiting from lower interest rates, rising 10% in the last 1.5 months. Industrial REITs were strong during the pandemic and are slightly softening now. Doesn't follow this name much anymore, but the rising tide of lower rates will lift REITs. Magna remains a key tenant, but GRT is slowly untethering from Magna.

HOLD

Diversified industrial globally. High quality properties. 10-12% discount to NAV. Focused on larger part of the market (over 300k square feet), where there's more vacancy. It needs to work through that. Likes the sector, stock's interesting at this level, keep owning it if you do.

COMMENT

Has done well in the past. It trades at a premium vs. peers. Instead, she owns Chartwell and CAP REIT.

BUY
Positively impacted by US tariffs.

Sounds counterintuitive, but WFG and trees are going to be beneficiaries. US still needs them, just going to pay higher prices.

GRT.UN is a good name. PKI works well here. Materials sector, with a name like NTR. 

There's even a part of the TSX that does well with a falling CAD, as earnings get amplified.

DON'T BUY

Solid balance sheet, so it's pretty defensive. Vacancy crept in last year, taking longer to lease due to economic uncertainty. Tariffs are the #1 question, and Magna is a large tenant. Same tariff issues with Europe. A show-me story. See his Top Picks.

BUY ON WEAKNESS

Canada's largest industrial REIT with properties in Canada, Europe and Asia. Increasing rents has helped the business, however, rents have appeared to plateaued lately. Concerns that large revenue stream from Magna will be at risk from tariffs. Would buy more shares upon stock price weakness. Strong business overall. 

HOLD

One of her 2 picks in the space, as warehouse and residential growth outshine retail REITs.

WAIT

Good assets. Headwinds: 1) MG is its largest tenant (at over 25% exposure), 2) midwest focus in US, where new supply has come on, so it's having a tough time filling up vacancies. Wait for a better entry point.

PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Apr 16/24, Down 6%)

26% of net operating income is from MG, so being impacted by tariffs. He calls this a second-derivative target of tariffs. Shares are trading as though MG is going to move its operations to the US, but he doesn't think it's equipped to do so.

BUY

Unique feature of large bays and international tenants, rather than smaller businesses. Europe, US, and Canada. Under extra pressure because of leases to MG; he sees no real risk there, as MG is very well run with low debt, actual exposure is ~3%. Industrial market has been punished unreasonably, good value for future.