Summer Sale

50% off Premium Yearly

00days
00hrs
00mins
00secs

NASDAQ:ETSY

Etsy Inc. (ETSY)

72.19
+2.71 (3.90%)
as of Jun 15, 2026, 8:00:00 pm Market Open.
82 watching
0
Investor Insights
star iconJun 15, 2026, 12:00 am

This summary was created by AI, based on 2 opinions in the last 12 months.

Etsy Inc. has garnered attention from financial experts with mixed reviews regarding its investment potential. On one hand, the company is regarded as profitable and trades at a relatively low price-to-earnings ratio of 14x, presenting a compelling case for value investors. However, there are execution challenges that the company must navigate, which raises some concerns about its operational effectiveness. Despite these issues, experts maintain a core belief in Etsy's inherent value, suggesting that it has the potential for improvement going forward. The general sentiment leans towards a cautious hold, with advice to consider buying if the stock retraces to its previous lows, indicating that there could be a favorable entry point for new investors.

consensus icon
Consensus
Hold
valuation icon
Valuation
Undervalued
review icon
Similar
eBay, EBAY
WEAK BUY
They report Wednesday. He expects the CEO to say positive things.
premiumPremium content

Unlock this Panic-proof Portfolio opinion with Stockchase Premium

Curated by Michael O'Reilly since 2020.
1550+ opinions with 4.81 rating (one of the best performing expert).

PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick May 04/21, Up 32.7%)Stockchase Research Editor: Michael O'Reilly Our PAST TOP PICK with ETSY is progressing well. It has acheived its objective at $226. To remain disciplined, we recommend covering half the position and trailing up the stop (from $140) to $170. If triggered, this would all but guarantee a combined net investment return over 16%.
BUY ON WEAKNESS
It rallied during the lockdown, but yesterday it reported gross merchandise sales growth slowed from 132% in Q1 to 13% in Q2 while revenue growth fell from 142% to 23%. We knew this decline was coming. However, management gave slightly weaker guidance for the next quarter and that's why the stock fell today though rebounded from its lows. They're still bringing in millions of new customers while habitual buyers was up YOY. Also, they made two exciting acqusitions--the Etsy of Brazil and a popular resale platform that GenXers love.
premiumPremium content

It's a Monthly Gems opinion which is available only for Stockchase Premium

Curated by Allan Tong since 2019.
99+ opinions with 4.15 rating.

TOP PICK
This tech name gets lost among the big egos of Tesla, Apple and Microsoft, but it performs just as well. This e-commerce platform in really an online marketplace selling vintage goods, homemade products and craft items from private sellers. We're talking jewelry, toys, clothing and furniture. As expected, business boomed during the lockdowns, so it runs the risk of being pigeonholed as a Covid play. In fact, year to date, Etsy shares have climbed only 14.4%, but its price swings have been wide, making this attractive to short-term traders. At the end of June, Etsy had returned to $200, but it soared at high as $245 in early March, then plunged below $160 in early May. The volatility is due more to the fickleness of Wall Street than the stock's earnings performance. After all, it's handily beaten the street in its last four quarters. Currently, 11 analysts would buy it and only one would hold. The price target is $220.50 or 11% upside. July should be as choppy as June as the market see-saws between tech and cyclicals, so be nimble and buy on one of those dips.
BUY

Like SHOP, they're supporting small business. They have over 90 active sellers from small businesses and just individuals to sell hand-crafted merchandise, not mass-produced junk. Customers are especially women making custom items like aprons. Etsy has made a fortune for them and for shareholders.

BUY
It's lost 40% in the rotation out of tech and into cyclicals, but recently the tide has turned with tech. Etsy popped 7% today alone. Today, it's buying its Brazilian peer.
BUY ON WEAKNESS
It's had a major run. Wait for a dip. Great company and CEO.
premiumPremium content

Unlock this Panic-proof Portfolio opinion with Stockchase Premium

Curated by Michael O'Reilly since 2020.
1550+ opinions with 4.81 rating (one of the best performing expert).

TOP PICK
Stockchase Research Editor: Michael O'Reilly This e-commerce company has been around a while. The pandemic allowed its platform to grow substantially. Earnings growth is expected to exceed 45% for the next five years, which makes the current 44x earnings, pretty decent value. We would buy this with a stop loss at $140, looking to achieve $226 -- upside over 32%. Yield 0% (Analysts’ price target is $226.13)
DON'T BUY
Even after the current and recent sell-off in growth/tech stock, this still trades at 9x sales which is still too high for a retail stock. Also, they last reported discouraging guidance.
BUY
They'll do well selling seeds as we enter gardening season. A wider tailwind is the continuing home improvement boom. Etsy now sells home improvement and gardening products.
BUY ON WEAKNESS

Wait till they report (in February); they always report conservatively. This, Square, Paypal and Shopify have run so much. You can buy some then wait for a pullback--this applies to all these stocks.

BUY

Along with PayPal, this is the future of retailing with a huge young (children and young adults) user base and further accelerated by the stay-at-home trend.

BUY
Very interesting name in the current environment of doing things from home and consumers not going out to stores. Probably will be here to stay. 100s of billions of retail revenue potential. Growth stock. Interesting even with its runup.
BUY
Part of his Fear Factor portfolio of stocks that will thrive with or without government stimulus during Covid Instead of buying something handmade at the mall, you can it online through Etsy. Safe. Sells all kinds of stuff online, supporting individuals and small businesses. The stock won't quit.
PAST TOP PICK

(A Top Pick May 14/18, Up 13%) It is a baby AMZN-Q. Connecting unique sellers with buyers. This is an interesting play, trading at half the multiple of AMZN-Q. It actually makes money.

Showing 16 to 30 of 31 entries