Stockchase Opinions

Brian Madden BCE Inc. BCE-T SELL May 23, 2025

When will it come back to investor's purchase price?

When making investment decisions, discard the idea of what your cost base is. It doesn't matter, it's water under the bridge. It's behaviourally and psychologically difficult to rip off the Band-Aid and admit that the initial decision was an error and to realize the loss. But remember that the loss is real already. What matters is where it's going in the future, regardless of what your cost is.

Stock sold off heavily in the last 2-3 years because it was anticipating the dividend cut, which finally came. Dividend is now sustainable. Total return expectations are likely confined to more or less what the dividend yield is. Doesn't expect shares to bounce back sharply in the short term. Look at Telus instead.

$29.520

Stock price when the opinion was issued

telephone utilities
It's the ideal tool to help you make quicker, more informed decisions for managing and tracking your investments.

You might be interested:

WEAK BUY

Everybody has baked in a 50% dividend cut, but you will still receive a pretty good yield. Long term, the fundamentals work for the telcos, but this could take years. Meanwhile, collect the dividends.

DON'T BUY

No issue with defaulting on bonds from any of the big 3 telcos. For the equity side: not a lot of growth, price competition, CRTC always making new rules. 

DON'T BUY

Cashflow does not cover dividend, and that's why there's talk of cutting it. Personally, he feels they'll never cut it, since most people who own it are looking for dividends. Better opportunities elsewhere.

HOLD
Investor is 62, planning to retire in 2 years. Down almost 50%, 7% position in the portfolio. Dollar cost average down?

7% in one stock is way too overweight. Expects to see a haircut on the dividend. Management hasn't been making the best decisions over the last year or two. He's been in this name since mid-$40s, not happy, but hasn't exited.

Instead, use ZWU.

HOLD
Average down?

The expectation is for a dividend cut of nearly 50% starting this month. We'll see if that happens. Technically, shares are having a rough go below both the 200-day and 200-week MAs. Earnings growth is sub-standard, even negative.

So, no, he wouldn't add at this stage. At some point, things could turn around a little bit.  Yield is 13.3% (would still be attractive even with a 50% cut). If you own, you can hold.

HOLD
Dividend cut by 56%.

Sold MLSE sports, bought a cable provider in the US. As late as Christmas, management was adamant that dividend would not be cut. The business is very difficult as a legacy communications company. Have to rely on mobile subscriptions. Competition's not getting easier. Stock's moved up, perhaps buyers are excited about it again. Yield is 6%.

HOLD

It has cut the dividend but the yield is still attractive. It is probably fairly priced and needs interest rates to come down. You can hold but could also take a look at Rogers.

DON'T BUY
Recourse for dividend cut?

Price competition, so pricing power has disappeared. Profitability flat. Building out 5G network increased debt. Immigration has slowed. All that had a huge impact on FCF and ability to pay dividend. Latest acquisition doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Wouldn't touch. He owns Telus and CCA.

For a class action lawsuit, you have to get investors together and prove that there was intention to mislead.

WEAK BUY
Does dividend cut make this a buy?

Yield is now 5.8%, so still a decent yield. Won't be any dividend growth. Now more transparency on payout ratio, and partnership with PSP on Ziply eases financial burden. Could be a valuation gap up. A buy today is not for a short-term pop in the stock, it would have to be a long-term buy and hold.

All telcos are facing slowing immigration, competitive pressures, regulatory pressure. Over the very long term will be OK, as they supply critical infrastructure. If recession, nice place to be for stability and defensiveness.