BMO EQUAL WEIGHT BANKS INDEX ETF (ZEB-T)

They're popular, because people want the extra yield, but they work only in some environments. Better when you expects markets to go down for 6-12 months (a correction). In rapid declines, like Covid, you get only some protection. But in a strong market, you give you the upside and lag the market a lot. Just owning ZEB since 2011, you would have made 10.71% annualized; ZWB 8.34%. So, use ZWB defensively at some point after a correction, say 10% or 15% down. Use ZEB in a strong rally. During strong declines, both ETFs fall roughly the same, but during the recent strong rally, ZEB was 16.98% and ZWB 14.85%.

Just the Canadian banks, no options, so will participate fully in a market rise.

Because there's no covered call strategy, if we get into a bull market you get full advantage of the upside. Upside hasn't been "called away" to provide an income stream. Perhaps lower income, but more capital appreciation along the way.

Basket of Canadian banks, no covered call. Past year's total return is nearly 14%. As well, better return over 3 years than ZWB.

Over the past year, total return for ZWB was ~9.5%.

The caller's question was on which of these ETF's to buy for a start-up portfolio for his 20-year-old daughter. He prefers more sectors to be covered in this situation so he suggested XEI. There are more multi-asset solutions as well. He also suggested lowering the risk tolerance for a beginner investor.

Banks in general are entering a normal level. Concerns about high interest rates and defaults are mostly in the past. Banks are good to hold here if you want some dividend-paying stocks. This one has a good strategy, holding the banks in equal weight.

Good long-term hold for the past 20 years, even through all the ups and downs of markets.

Equal weight of the 6 Canadian banks. Very simple, fees have been cut. Over the long haul, outperforms ZWB. ZWB gives you more yield in the present, but diminishes upside participation in a growth market.

To choose, he asks clients about yield requirements and time horizon.

Great option to get exposure to Canadian banks. Excellent option for long term investors. 

Basket of Canadian banks, equal weight, no covered call. One-year return is 13.3%. Whereas the ZWB, which applies a covered call strategy, has a one-year return of 9.1%

(The March 2023 US regional bank meltdown was shocking, and how it happened was stupid.) He sold this recently.

Buy ZEB (no covered call) if you believe the banks will recover.

Low MER, but not a good performance the past few years. Banks hit by rising interest rates. Good time to buy given low valuation. Would recommend adding slowly.