Stockchase Opinions

Sandy McIntyre Freehold Royalties Ltd FRU-T COMMENT Dec 10, 2012

Most of these types of stocks in the context of today’s natural gas prices and western Canadian oil prices, are distributing more than they should. In his view, the dividend is too high and will likely be right sized to reflect the current reality of a $20 spread under WTI and a discounted AACO (?) relative to NYMX on natural gas.

$21.720

Stock price when the opinion was issued

Financial Services
It's the ideal tool to help you make quicker, more informed decisions for managing and tracking your investments.

You might be interested:

BUY

Likes exposure to energy and energy prices without the exploration costs. Stock's come down on issuing equity for recent acquisition. Substantial dividend in the space, minimal risk. Good value. Compelling yield of 8.3%.

HOLD

No operational risk with liabilities from wellbore. High margin business. If "Drill baby bill" materializes, will not be good for company. Dividend is stable. Most of returns have been generated by dividend growth. Good for yield seeking investors. 

TOP PICK

They just bought a US company. More than 60% of cash flow comes from the US, so they are better insulated from tariffs than peers. Pay over an 8% dividend. Will convert USD revenues into CAD, which is good. Oil prices should be stable.

(Analysts’ price target is $17.10)
BUY

Believes dividend is safe. Strong business with good capital discipline. Royalty business capital light. Under valued business. 

BUY

A major holding. It yields 9%, which is defendable even at lower oil prices. It's a royalty company, so there's no exploration risk. They have expanded into the US; hopes their next quarter shows US stability. They have done accretive deals in the US and are expanding in the Permian, because there is less room in Canada. Expect modest capital appreciation, but you get a stable 9% dividend. Good for income investors.

SELL

Support level around $13 was broken. Not great news from his viewpoint. He'd want to know if the company is stable enough to continue paying the dividend. If yes, it'll probably move up again.

BUY

Small position for her, actively traded. Energy royalties are still a steady play. A mid-tier champ. Zero operational risk. Dividend hike, so she doesn't see it being cut. Yield is ~8.5%. Oil above $70 keeps royalty cash flowing. Drop in crude price or a global demand wobble would impact it. Value of 10/10, fundamentals 10/10. 

(Analysts’ price target is $17.00)
BUY

Won't double this year, but likes the consistent 8.3% dividend yield. As a royalty play, doesn't have the same commodity exposure as producers, though can be impacted by negative sentiment in the energy sector. Recent acquisitions in US, and this seems to be the new focus. Great risk/reward.

BUY
Trevor Rose’s Insights - Trevor’s most-liked answers from 5i Research

We would consider FRU a decent royalty company. Payout ratio is 66% and the balance sheet is decent Debt is barely 1X cash flow. There is cyclical risk here and the dividend has been cut in other cycles. But barring further declines in commodity prices, the dividend is probably secure for a while. The stock is reasonably cheap, for a royalty company and we think it is decently managed. We would be OK owning this for a sector investor looking primarily for income. The last quarter was good. 
Unlock Premium - Try 5i Free

BUY

Boring name that pays you a 9.5% dividend yield, sustainable down to about $46 WTI. Not on anyone's radar screen. Asset quality not outstanding, but trades at half the multiple of other names. No exploration risk.