Opinions Eric Nuttall
Bonavista Energy CorpBNP.TOCOMMENTMay 27, 2016
Eric NuttallUnknown
$3.35
Stock price when the opinion was issued
$0.04
As of Aug 14, 2020. Market Open.
oilgas
It's the ideal tool to help you make quicker, more informed decisions for managing and tracking your investments.
You might be interested:
SELL
What to do with the Bonavista debt deal? https://globalnews.ca/news/7088006/bonavista-energy-calgary-company/ A sad ending to a good company with fine assets and managers. Problem was that their debt was maturing in November 2020 and debt holders refused to extend that debt two-three years. BNP also couldn't get debt relief from EDC or BDC. For shareholders, it's a tough choice now. You have three options: 1) you can wait for the 5 cents after shareholders vote in July, 2) sell in the open market now at 7.5 cents, or 3) own a part of this as a private company with no liquidity or trading value until there's an exit strategy 3-4 years later. He will sell (option 2).
Josef SchachterOwned
oilgas
PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Feb 28/19, Down 58%) The market is concerned about their balance sheet. He still likes the cash flow outlook as it trades below 1 times cash flow. They are 30% liquids. They have a new large shareholder who holds 15% of the outstanding shares.
Josef SchachterOwned
oilgas
PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Jul 16/18, Down 70%) Good cash flow, using excess to pay down debt. It will survive. They're a beneficiary of apportionment. Will benefit from better nat gas prices.
Josef SchachterOwned
oilgas
COMMENT
BNP and BXE Both are carrying high levels of debt. BNP-T has been paying down debt and will try to keep production flat. He intends to buy more of both. BXE-T will be doing a 12:1 reverse split on the shares sometime in June.
Josef SchachterOwned
oilgas
SELL
From a trading perspective you can take a shot and buy it. But you want to flip it. It is not as cheap for the risk. Balance sheet is heavy with net debt over cash flow is 5.3 (you don't want to be over 3) They have bigger problems. Tough one. The Management has skin in the game but their balance sheet problems are very big.
oilgas
PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Apr 03/18, Down 4%) Pays a dividend. Focused on paying down debt and keeping volumes down. If they pay down debt this year, then in 2020 they can start growing the company. Trading cheaply.
Josef SchachterOwned
oilgas
TOP PICK
Natural gas pick. Likes the company. Cheap here. Paying down debt in 2019. $3.50 target in next year or two is reasonable. Balance sheet's improving. Yield is 3.48%. (Analysts’ price target is $1.45)
Josef SchachterOwned
oilgas
PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Mar 16/18, Down 6%) They exceed his cash flow projections. They paid down debt. They are doing the right thing in paying down debt along the way. His target is $3.50.
Josef SchachterOwned
oilgas
TOP PICK
Their focus is to keep production flat. They beat his last year's forecast for cash flow. They are paying down debt. $5.95 is their book value. NAV is $4.64. He owns the stock personally. His one year target is $3.50. This is ridiculously cheap. (Analysts’ price target is $1.39)
Josef SchachterOwned
oilgas
PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Jan 10/18, Down 37%) It is even cheaper now. They did not do the loan growth he thought they would. Right now it is at about a 30% discount to book value. Right now it is a value trap. You could buy this if China and Europe have turned around.
Robert LauzonOwned
oilgas
PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Jan 15/18, Down 35%) All these natural gas stocks have been beaten up. It bottomed last year. We have a big decline in the storage data last week. He thinks we will see it go up to $4. He would buy on weakness
Josef SchachterOwned
oilgas
PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Dec 18/17, Down 47%) A year from now all three of these names should look really good. They have positive cash flow because they have firm hedges. Be bought stock last week.
Josef SchachterOwned
oilgas
His only hang-up is that they have $1.2 billion in debt and just raised $100 million. They still have $1.1 billion of debt, and relating that to the amount of cash flow they’ve been generating, it is still about 3.5X, which is too high. He would rather buy names that have way less debt, which means that as oil prices recover they will be generating more free cash flow than they can deploy into the field, and can compress their multiples.