Stock price when the opinion was issued
A young company that's bought several companies and have accumulated a lot of heavy oil production. In their favour are the shrinking differential with WCS oil and lot of drilling inventory, but not in their favour is liquidity is tight, because a single energy fund owns so many shares and likely won't sell. It boasts a decent 15% cash flow. Are better peers to buy though he's tempted by this.
He's not an M&A guy. If you want a really good answer, ask somebody else ;) A board will often reject something like this because they think it should be higher. And maybe a competitor will come along with a better offer.
Right now, if you believe that because of what's going on in the Middle East we might have persistently high oil prices for some period of time, then a lot of these energy drillers will benefit.
In the energy business, scale will be essential going forward.
Good deal buying Pipestone (not good for Pipestone shareholders). No liquidity in stock. Not trading at largest enough discount to justify investment. Better names in sector. Lots of debt also a concern. Hard for large investors to buy meaningful amount of shares.