Stockchase Opinions

John Hood Horizons Active Preferred Share ETF HPR-T HOLD May 11, 2017

Active preferred share ETF. ZPR-T is almost entirely resets, but HR-T is 70% resets and 30% perpetuals. If there is another down stroke in interest rates, this one could retain its value more. But ZPR-T could retain its value better during rate increases. Do a little of each. He is not a big fan. If you need the income then stay with it.

$9.280

Stock price when the opinion was issued

E.T.F.'s
It's the ideal tool to help you make quicker, more informed decisions for managing and tracking your investments.

You might be interested:

HOLD

Preferred shares are a great investment due to the favorable tax treatment. With active management you are getting a great benefit. They will be holding a balance of fixed versus floating holdings. A casual investor can get caught in the various different covenants associated with this class. He thinks this is an excellent way to add preferred exposure to your portfolio.

BUY

ZPR-T vs HPR-T? Preferred shares in Canada are subject to resets, so they’re a great thing when interest rates rise. But when rates go down, they get creamed. It’s unlikely that rates will go down anytime soon. ZPR-T is laddered, and very short term and floating rate. Not a bad strategy. A better strategy would be HPR-T, which is actively managed by Fierra a fantastic manager in the fixed income space. The price on HPR-T is kinda in the same category as ZPR-T but you get the advantage of Fierra without paying a lot. Prefers HPR-T to ZPR-T.

HOLD
He likes this and ZPR-T, but in general is not a big fan of preferred shares as he feels they have the yield of bonds and the risk of stocks. He holds it as a partial position, but does not view it as a good place to park cash. The yield on HPR-T is over 4%.
BUY
Preferreds are Jekyll and Hyde: when markets are calm, they act normally and give you a coupon-like return, but when markets act crazy, they act like an equity. All preferred share indices have declined 10-15% because of the rate reset and credit. When there's equity duress and rate resets, these ETFs go down. Instead, buy an actively managed ETF; it's worth the extra fee.
SELL ON STRENGTH
HPR outperforms the larger index. It's interest-rate sensitive. Pays a good yield. However, if the Bank of Canada cuts rates, this will decline 10-15%. This is a tactical buy, so sell on a rally of 5-10%. Not a long-term buy.
DON'T BUY
Getting a decent yield. Need to keep in mind rate reset preferred shares versus perpetual rates. Not a fan of preferred since you get the yield of a bond with the risk of a stock. Would rather have covered calls and Canadian banks.
WATCH
Pretty darn good, actively managed ETF. This is the way to go rather than picking your own preferreds. But you can see it's struggled. If we're in a Fed loosening cycle, with rates dropping, you'd want to own perpetuals, not rate resets. As rates fall, your coupon will fall as well. But if you think rates will ratchet up, then it's good.
DON'T BUY

For recent years, he's been off and on preferred shares. Preferreds are volatile. When interest rates plunged 2-3 years ago, this asset class got reamed. HPR pays a big dividend, but also offers huge volatility. Also, it lacks the growth of stocks but carries the volatility. He had a terrible experience with this. Look at ZUP-T, which covers US preferreds which are largely fixed-rate, a key difference to Canadian preferreds. Also, US preferreds are less volatile than Canadians.

BUY ON WEAKNESS

Likes active approach to preferred asset class.
Very sensitive to interest rates.
Would wait to buy when prices fall.
Very volatile.

DON'T BUY

Preferred share market is risky - not a good place for average investor.
Not much upside with lots of downside risk.
Income oriented investors have better options.
Canadian Dividend Index a better product.