Stock price when the opinion was issued
We recently added more CS to our model portfolio and consider it a buy. We are not fond of targets, especially short term, but $13 to $14 we think is possible.
Unlock Premium - Try 5i Free
Insider selling is never a 'great' sign but there can be lots of reasons for it. Insiders still own more than $200M in stock. We can also live with a bit of insider selling on a stock that has risen 41% in the past year. The future will likely still be dictated more by copper prices than any trading activity. EPS is expected to more than triple in 2025. If CS can achieve this growth, the stock should do well.
Unlock Premium - Try 5i Free
Copper is one of the reasons he thinks we're starting a new cycle. Both silver and copper have broken out to new highs; both have industrial uses and should benefit from a strengthening economy. If cyclical commodities are breaking out to new highs, then copper should continue to work into 2027.
His firm's fundamental analyst has it rated Outperform. On the chart, you can see the 4-year cycle reset in 2022 as well as the cycle reset in April 2025. If he's correct that we're starting a new cycle, this name should have similar upside to the last one. Sees upside into 2027; 20-30% over the next 12-18 months. No dividend.
We can't do much about the cyclicality of the metals sector. It will always be cyclical, and nothing should be considered a 'buy and forget' stock. Much will depend on economic growth, particularly in China. It is interesting right now in that China is weak but copper is strong. It is possible investors are seeing China as 'bottoming' and there are also supply concerns (i.e. the recent closure of a large mine in Panama). The sector is cyclical, and thus valuations are usually low. CS is more expensive at 16X earnings, because it is growing fast. From a loss last year it is expected to earn 28c a share this year and then a near-double to 54c next year. Debt is fairly high but cash flow is also growing nicely. We would be comfortable owning it in a size reflective of its risk. We might not add to a current position as the price rise naturally brings position size up.
Unlock Premium - Try 5i Free