In unfolding bull markets, you always have these periods. People are losing their heads as they try to figure out what to do.
Everyone's looking for that one clarion event -- midterm elections, Anthropic trade, the shoe dropping from NVDA, shorting of AMD. Once people identify that in their minds, and then point to earnings being so good, they expect markets to recover immediately. But it doesn't happen like that.
We've been through a series of disappointments. Recently, and most particularly, some Federal Reserve officials have been saying that they need to raise by 50 bps. The market is not priced for 50 bps more, and it changes the whole multiple of the market.
Combine that with the uncertainty of the Democratic win -- what are they going to do come January, and how much are they going to slow down the AI buildout? People hate uncertainty. It wasn't the individual investors who started selling, it was the hedge funds.
This is what it looks like when big money is trying to get a very crowded trade through a narrow channel. Fund managers are trying to get their numbers in good shape for the end of the year, so they're taking risk off. And that's bleeding through to individual investors, who are starting to lose hope.
The washout has been so good, we're at a point that any sort of positive catalyst can have a reverse domino effect of going to the other side. But we don't yet know what that positive catalyst will be.
It could be the Fed backing off, but we won't know that for a few weeks. Or the Democrats might end up being fairly benign in their approach. Those things will take a while to play out.
Recent market moves are really saying that it would be a policy error for the Fed to go as far as to raise by 50 bps. Markets rolled over really badly when Fed Governor Waller indicated 2 days ago that the Fed may need to "shock" people with its next rate increase. That's when the real market carnage started.
Bank ROEs are looking really good. Balance sheets are much better. Regulatory constraints removed. On balance, do better with higher interest rates. Improving NIMs. PCLs have been tame. Nothing not to like, other than....
...valuation. It's spiked. Is that level sustainable going into earnings next week? If you extrapolate from the US banks, then yes. However, this market has so much blood in the streets and so many things are so much cheaper, there's much more compelling value elsewhere.
One reason the market is in a contest here is because 10-year bonds in the US are now paying well. Why go through all the drama if you can get almost 6% on risk-free money?
He believes in the Mag 7 and that they're printing money. On balance, they're an ethical group (maybe he's naive), and the growth they're calling for is as they see it. He wouldn't buy the uber-risky neocloud bonds, but he'd be fine with buying Mag 7 bonds.
That's really important. For the last 2 years, Canada has been one of the strongest, outperforming-everybody stock markets in the world of major, developed stock markets. A lot of it's been propelled by large rallies in mining and energy. For example, the price of gold exploded from $3k to $5k. Copper went from $3 to $6, oil went from $60 to $110.
Now we're seeing some of that go back the other way. Copper, oil, and gold are all coming off. The move in oil is related to war developments, so it could come back again.
The one most concerning to him is copper. It's a measure of demand in the global economy for resources; like a proxy for everything because it has so many applications. Slowdown raises questions whether the global economy is slowing. It could, considering how much inflation has impacted commodity prices (among other things). It's like a circle, and it looks as though we're heading for the other side of that circle.
So far it looks like a correction. If we see falling commodity prices, then inflation comes off, and central banks don't have to raise rates. But that can take a year to play out. We don't know how long it'll take the central banks and markets to adjust to all of this.
One thing we are seeing is that resource prices are, finally, lower than they were 4-6 weeks ago. It's at a point where it could start to make a difference. He noticed it first last week, when he went out to fill up his tank. Gas was the cheapest it's been in months!
Overall, he's neutral through to the end of the year. Historically, November/December has been a good time for markets. But in 2018, the last time there was a midterm election and Trump was president, the markets had a correction in Nov/Dec. It's one of those things where it could go either way. Lots of moving pieces.
But there are always opportunities. ;)
Tech, communications, and energy are all rolling down. So what's going up?
Healthcare is #1. Financials are #2. Also seeing strength in industrials, consumer staples, consumer discretionary. Basically we're moving from tech to the type of older-economy stocks. Even within tech, we're seeing a rotation back into software, IT services, and your standard, less-volatile, more-boring tech. Back into tried-and-true. Not the fun, exciting AI stuff.
Depends on your investing horizon. If you're a long-term investor, you want to look at a long-term chart. If you're medium-term (a few months), then look at daily/weekly/monthly charts. Very short-term charts are for very short-term traders (if you're not a short-term trader, you shouldn't even be looking at those charts, as they'll drive you crazy :).
At his firm, they buy for a 6-18 month time horizon. They use longer-term charts -- point-and-figure at the end of the day. They look for longer-term trends. They're medium- to long-term investors.
The damage has certainly been widespread. The tech-heavy Nasdaq 100 is in correction territory, down more than 10% off highs. The S&P 500 isn't as bad, down only 3-5% off highs. But within the index itself, more than 50% of its members are down more than 20%. That's bear-market territory.
His firm sees all this as a result of concern around interest rates, the geopolitical picture in both Europe and the Middle East, and concerns around the sustainability of AI spending to garner returns.
Investing 101: Canadian Depositary Receipts (CDRs):
Canadian Depositary Receipts (CDRs) are a relatively new concept that has been introduced in recent years to help Canadians gain access to U.S. blue-chip stocks in a simplified, low-cost manner.
Canadian Depositary Receipts (CDRs) are securities that trade on the NEO Exchange in Canada, and the concepts are essentially similar to American Depository Receipts (ADRs) that are listed on American exchanges. CDRs give Canadians access to some of the largest US companies listed on NYSE and NASDAQ through a Canadian exchange in Canadian dollars. CDRs are issued and managed by the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC). There are no management fees, so the main cost that investors will incur is the buy/sell commission on trades.
PROS:
Accessibility in registered accounts: CDRs can be held within registered accounts, similar to other Canadian-listed securities. We think CDRs can fit in any account, but generally, growth investments are usually better in a TFSA.
Currency-hedge feature: There is a currency-hedge built into the shares. That said, the built-in currency hedge has a certain cost and may not perfectly track changes in track exchange rate. There are no management fees associated with CDRs, but CIBC does make money on the currency hedge. While investors do not see this as a charge, it does impact net asset value. This cost is estimated to be about 0.50% annually.
The benefit of currency hedging could be explained through this example. For instance, if the Canadian dollar strengthens relative to the US dollar, then that investment will lag behind the equivalent US stock, and vice versa, if the US dollar appreciates, the CDR will appreciate more than the US equivalent. As investors might expect, this is simply a currency call.
Fractional ownership: One of the key advantages of CDRs is a lower share price. CDRs are structured so that the price per share always starts at $20, giving a wider array of investors access to these global companies. In simple terms, CDRs represent fractional interest in the underlying US shares.
CONS:
Illiquidity: The primary disadvantage of owning CDRs is their lower liquidity than the US shares. Consequently, a wider bid-ask spread could result in a higher cost when buying/selling for investors.
Withholding taxes still apply: Despite trading on Canadian exchanges, the underlying assets are still U.S. shares, which are subject to withholding taxes for dividends received (except in an RRSP account).
Limited selection: Since the product is still new, only a handful of well-known U.S. mega-cap stocks are currently available. Most small- and mid-cap U.S. companies are not yet offered as CDRs.
Conclusion
Overall, we are comfortable with CDRs for investors who want lower-priced exposure to U.S. securities with a built-in Canadian hedge. They are not fundamentally different from owning the underlying shares, aside from their price, the currency hedge, and where they trade. The underlying U.S. shares are held by CIBC, which issues the CDRs.
We generally prefer non-hedged products and would favour owning the U.S. shares directly if investors have the capital available and are comfortable with currency exposure. That said, we view CDRs as a good complementary option within a portfolio, and we would be comfortable buying them for U.S. company exposure.
Unlock Premium - Try 5i Free