50% off Premium Yearly
BMO S&P/TSX Oil & Gas ETFZEO.TOCOMMENTJul 22, 2014Stock price when the opinion was issued
As of Jun 17, 2026. Market Open.
He's in the camp that any advantage to the Canadian oil industry is transient, not long term. We need structural change in how the Canadian government looks at our ability as Canadians to distribute one of our best assets to the world. Until that happens, Canada will always trade at a discount to just about everywhere else in the world that sees O&G in a different light.
If your view is that the benefit is longer lasting, you'd move toward small caps. So equal-weight ZEO would potentially give you a better return than XEG. But that's not his outlook.
Since the war broke out, XEG is outperforming. The market sees recent moves as temporary, not permanent.
ENCC is the Global X oil and gas, covered call, income ETF. Compare to ZEO, which boasts 13% this year vs. ENCC's 12%; while over 3 years, it's 46% vs. 40%. The difference lies in the covered writing; you sell some of that future growth to create income now. That's neither good or bad. Also, gas and oil stocks are more volatile, though that makes call premiums higher but adds income.
Not devastating, but there are other things to do with capital. With the current macro economic situation, keep this allocation smaller. Follow through in the markets and some outperformance in energy would be encouraging. It's probably going to be a volume game, not a price game.
Challenge with buying US ETFs that participate in MLPs is that they're not favourable to a Canadian investor. Withholding tax of 15-30%. Be very, very careful on the MLPs. If you want gas exposure, think about XEG or ZEO. Most bang for the buck would be the HED, with small cap exposure. Small caps have more operating leverage if you're confident gas prices will rise. HOG is a bit more conservative.
Actually iUnits S&P/TSX Capped Energy (XEG-T) has done much better, simply because Canadian Natural Resources (CNQ-T) and Suncor (SU-T), which are 30%-40% of the index, did so well over the last 6 months. As the energy business continues to do well, the gains will become more evenly distributed. Owning something like this in addition to, or instead of XEG would be the way to go if you like energy.