Stock price when the opinion was issued
Shareholder returns are a little lighter than peers. Valuation a bit higher than peers. Cashflow per share growth is in line with peers, as is the payout ratio. Balance sheet better than peers.
How many boxes does it tick? Ends up being fair. He wouldn't be buying a big oil company right now in front of the OPEC meeting.
Is top of class in energy. Nobody knows where energy prices will go, but if they go down, XOM can produce results and pay dividends and buy shares back. Problem is, nobody cares about the energy sector.