Stock price when the opinion was issued
Yes. In a balanced portfolio, having some component of GICs does make sense. But you lose liquidity, there's reinvestment risk at lower rates upon maturity, and there's an opportunity cost by not being in the market.
Something with smart flexibility, like a money market fund, lets you get your money out whenever you want. Because we don't know what the world's going to look like in 1 month, 6 months, or a year from now.
Right now and for the next year or two, interest rates are priced in to coming down in both Canada and the US. He doesn't think they're going to come down as much as is priced in.
In Canada, 5 x 25 bps rate cuts are priced in looking out one year. That's about right, and means that interest rates will be 125 bps lower a year from today. Overnight rate now is 4.25%, so 125 bps takes us down to ~3%. So a 3-year GIC would be in the range 3-3.5%, compared to the 5% of today.
When the government lowers rates, GIC rates go down. And vice versa. We're now on a rate-cut path because we're worried about a slower economy.
Though equities did end up outperforming, he's not unhappy. This was a great anchor in a very tumultuous year. Let clients sleep at night. Chances of a recession were very high, and it was time to be defensive.
An investor could do the same thing today. Still really juicy. It's a bird in the hand.