Rating Card

premiumPremium content

Unlock Expert's Rating and Top Picks Portfolio

Curated by Michael O'Reilly since 2020
1550+ opinions with 4.81 rating (one of the best performing expert)

Latest Top Picks

Stock Opinions by Richard Fogler

Most recent Opinions go here

Be up to date, don’t miss your chance.

COMMENT
Optimistic on markets with potential rate cuts coming?

He's always optimistic, so the answer is yes. The economy looks OK. He did look at the jobs report. The forecast for Q3 in the US was 3%, and it'll probably still be close to that. Interesting thing is that with today's jobs report weaker than last time, who's Trump going to fire this time?

Good chance of a rate cut in the US, with or without jobs being weak. Trump's pushing hard for that. That should be positive for the market. Doesn't seem to be a recession in the wind, so we should have a reasonable stock market.

Canada's job reports have been pretty weak for a couple of sessions now. The economy is weaker than we hoped, and it's all tariff-related.

COMMENT
Valuations in the US.

Widespread talk about that market being overpriced at 25x PE. If you pull out the Magnificent 7, the less-magnificent 493 are trading at 16.6x PE and that's not a lot. It's below the average of the last 20 years. 

His team buys 25 stocks in the US, so he doesn't really care about the market per se except for the beta part of it. He looks for companies that are quite cheap, and he's found some.

COMMENT
Fundamental resilience.

He looks only at companies that are fundamentally sound, with businesses that will substantially increase in value over the next number of years. Looks for catalysts that aren't yet recognized in the stock price, so they're cheap on certain metrics. His team's view would be different than the consensus view.

That strategy works well over time, and it works well in slowdowns.

DON'T BUY
Yield is 5.8%.

Chart's quite volatile. Currently paying out a high proportion of cashflow to cover the dividend. So it's not reinvesting substantially in the business. Making acquisitions, but revenue hasn't changed one iota.

HOLD
Hold, or add more?

In the hot part of the market. Momentum of the business is decidedly positive. Not cheap, but the return has been great. His firm doesn't buy at high prices, because when there's a hiccup (which you can't forecast) it can turn into pneumonia. That's the risk.

BUY

New CEO in 2017 vowed to increase profitability, and it's materialized in operating margins, earnings, and cashflow. Thinks that will continue. Rapidly getting into self-driving, which apparently will dominate the space over the next number of years. Stock has a long way to go over next 5 years.

DON'T BUY

Trades at 176x PE, not exactly bargain basement. Musk's antics in politics have turned non-Americans away. EV sales in general have stalled. He saw a BYD vehicle in France, and it's way more beautiful than a Tesla and 2/3 the price. Lots of competition. Musk's compensation demands are egregious.

RISKY

Good company, well managed. Doing well, and that should continue. High beta stock, will return 25% more than the market does on the upside (yay), but 25% or more on the downside (boo). So it's a call on the market.

BUY

Underperformed peers last 2 years, but has caught up some since US mess put to bed. New management seems really good. New strategy to be laid out on September 29th investor day. Despite cap, still lots of opportunity in US.

PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Sep 11/24, Up 23%)

He's owned this one for 10 years. Private equity has cooled off in the last little while, but that's just noise. The good businesses are growing dramatically. Added insurance, a huge growth business. US has just approved private equity in 401(k) accounts, a $13T market of which private equity is only 1% (but could rise to 5-7% over time).

PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Sep 11/24, Up 21%)

If he's holding something, it means he'd still buy it today. Sold one business last year, generated lots of cash to bring finances in line. Lots of cashflow to reinvest in the business. Expects strong profitability over next few years, with 20% for at least next 3 years.

PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Sep 11/24, Up 86%)

(Taken private 12 August 2025.)

DON'T BUY

Likes companies with recurring and predictable cashflows. Very volatile business, and you can see this in a long-term chart. Too tough to predict. You only need to own a few stocks, so you might as well own those you can predict with some degree of certainty.

SELL

Investment in KEY is just that, an investment, not control. That's not a positive. Look elsewhere. Prefers TD or RY. 

WEAK BUY
Investor's done well over 9 years.

If true that economy's slowing, then people trade down and this name will do better than average. Over time, economy will grow. Has been a superb company. Extraordinarily well-managed. Doesn't own because always too expensive.

Showing 1 to 15 of 124 entries