TSE:ASTL

Algoma Steel Group Inc (ASTL.TO)

5.15
+0.02 (0.39%)
as of Jul 14, 2026, 8:00:01 pm Market Open.
88 watching
0
Investor Insights
star iconJul 14, 2026, 12:00 am

This summary was created by AI, based on 4 opinions in the last 12 months.

Algoma Steel Group Inc (ASTL) is a company currently facing significant challenges, as highlighted by several experts. While there is potential for improvement, especially given the recent performance of the sector ETF, there are concerns related to the company's cash burn and turnaround efforts. The upcoming renewal of the USMCA brings about speculation regarding tariff adjustments, which adds another layer of uncertainty. Some analysts express a cautious interest in the company due to the deteriorating business outlook, indicating it may be a good time to approach such companies, but recommend careful consideration given the current market conditions. Overall, there is a sense that while the steel sector has intriguing elements, ASTL may not be the optimal choice for investment at this time.

consensus icon
Consensus
Cautious
valuation icon
Valuation
Undervalued
review icon
Similar
Nucor, NUE
DON'T BUY

The ETF for the sector made a new all-time high yesterday. This one is a special situation, improved recently. Trying to turn things around, and he's not a big fan of turnarounds. Burning cash.

TOP PICK

A speculative choice, not sleep-at-night, but intriguing. USMCA is coming up for renewal, with intense pressure from industry to get tariffs down and return to some semblance of a reasonable NA economy. 

Big question is how will Trump respond (and that's why it's speculative :). No dividend.

(Analysts’ price target is $7.38)
DON'T BUY

He always likes to look at the sector first. SLX is the US ETF that covers the whole steel sector. You want to see how your stock is trading relative to its sector. ASTL wouldn't be his top choice. If the sector's doing OK, but a name isn't performing, you have to ask yourself if you really want to be there.

But the sector itself looks really interesting. 

PARTIAL BUY

Example of a stock that's a really tough call right now, simply because current business outlook is so absolutely miserable. But this is actually when he starts to get interested in companies -- when you have the worst-case situation.

He recently started buying IFP.

WAIT
Amid new tariff threats.

Go back to the 2017 timeframe and look at the last time he did this with steel and aluminum. Cheap for a reason. Need a high tolerance for risk and volatility to put a position on right now. These names are down, compared to US names that are up (today in particular).

There's an opportunity there, but don't rush in today. Get closer to where there's some sort of resolution.

BUY

XME was among the strongest performers this morning, up almost 7%. Some view that protectionism would be good for the NA steel producer. Cyclical, fits the inflation theme. Hasn't done a lot of work on this one, but technical setup is good.

DON'T BUY
Trevor Rose’s Insights - Trevor’s most-liked answers from 5i Research

ALC is kind of a 'sleeper' stock, offering not much excitement but a low valuation and decent dividend. There is little growth, though, and 2025 estimated earnings will be below the level of 2021. It also has a fairly levered balance sheet. We have always thought it would make a good privatization candidate, but that is not enough reason to give it a strong endorsement. We would not miss it if sold. 
Unlock Premium - Try 5i Free

premiumPremium content

Unlock this Panic-proof Portfolio opinion with Stockchase Premium

Curated by Michael O'Reilly since 2020.
1550+ opinions with 4.81 rating (one of the best performing expert).

PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Aug 01/23, Down 0.1%)Stockchase Research Editor: Michael O'Reilly

Our PAST TOP PICK with ASTL has triggered its stop at $10.  To remain disciplined, we recommend covering the position at this time.  We combined with our past recommendations, this will result in a net investment gain of 12%  

premiumPremium content

Unlock this Panic-proof Portfolio opinion with Stockchase Premium

Curated by Michael O'Reilly since 2020.
1550+ opinions with 4.81 rating (one of the best performing expert).

PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Aug 01/23, Up 24.7%)Stockchase Research Editor: Michael O'Reilly

Our PAST TOP PICK with ASTL has achieved our $12.50 target.  To be disciplined, we recommend covering half the position and trailing up the stop (from $9.25) to $10.00 at this time.  

premiumPremium content

Unlock this Panic-proof Portfolio opinion with Stockchase Premium

Curated by Michael O'Reilly since 2020.
1550+ opinions with 4.81 rating (one of the best performing expert).

PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Aug 01/23, Up 11.2%)Stockchase Research Editor: Michael O'Reilly

Our PAST TOP PICK with ASTL is progressing well.  To remain disciplined, we recommend trailing up the stop (from $8.50) to $9.25 at this time.  

PARTIAL BUY
Trevor Rose’s Insights - Trevor’s most-liked answers from 5i Research

EPS of $0.24 missed estimates of $0.3067 and revenues of $732.6M beat expectations of $692.38M. Revenue of $732.6M, increased from $599.2M, and income from operations rose substantially. Its Adjusted EBITDA margin shrunk from 13.8% in the prior year to 11.1% in the recent quarter. Its results were negatively impacted by declines in steel prices due to labor stoppages at auto manufacturers in the US. Management expects a recovery in steel demand and pricing, however. Its balance sheet expanded, and its free cash flow grew. This was an OK quarter, and share prices are largely unchanged. It trades at a decent valuation of 0.4X forward sales and 7.1X forward earnings and pays a dividend of 2.7%. It may hover around these prices until a recovery in steel demand and pricing returns.
Unlock Premium - Try 5i Free

premiumPremium content

Unlock this Panic-proof Portfolio opinion with Stockchase Premium

Curated by Michael O'Reilly since 2020.
1550+ opinions with 4.81 rating (one of the best performing expert).

TOP PICK
Stockchase Research Editor: Michael O'Reilly

ASTL is one of Canada's largest steel producers.  It trades at 6x earnings, under book value and supports a 19% ROE.  Previously reported earnings indicated cost over runs and project delays that we feel have been fully discounted into the price.  Meanwhile plate mill modernization is moving ahead of schedule.  Its dividend is backed by a payout ratio under 20% of cash flow.  We recommend a stop-loss at $8.50, looking to achieve $12.50 -- upside potential over 21%.  Yield 2.6%  

(Analysts’ price target is $12.75)
BUY ON WEAKNESS

Commodity cycle is key input for steel sector.
If economy is expanding, good time to buy steel companies.
Expecting a hard recession, so would not recommend buying.
Wait to buy when market/economy has fallen more.


WATCH

Been pressured in recent months. The market is pricing in a recession risk later this year. Wouldn't sell it now. Trades at a discount. Wait and see how things develop.

premiumPremium content

Unlock this Panic-proof Portfolio opinion with Stockchase Premium

Curated by Michael O'Reilly since 2020.
1550+ opinions with 4.81 rating (one of the best performing expert).

PAST TOP PICK
(A Top Pick Feb 09/23, Down 13.6%)Stockchase Research Editor: Michael O'Reilly

Our PAST TOP PICK with ASTL has triggered its stop at $9.50.  To remain disciplined, we recommend covering the position at this time.  This will result in a net investment loss of 2%, when combined with the previous buy recommendation.

Showing 1 to 15 of 121 entries

Algoma Steel Group Inc (ASTL.TO) Frequently Asked Questions

What is Algoma Steel Group Inc stock symbol?

Algoma Steel Group Inc is a Canadian stock, trading under the symbol ASTL.TO (previously ASTL-T on Stockchase) on the Toronto Stock Exchange (ASTL-CT). It is usually referred to as TSX:ASTL or ASTL.TO

Is Algoma Steel Group Inc a buy or a sell?

In the last year, 4 stock analysts issued a Buy, Sell, or Hold rating on ASTL.TO (previously ASTL-T on Stockchase). 2 analysts recommended to BUY and 2 analysts recommended to SELL the stock. The latest stock analyst rating is DON'T BUY. Read the latest stock experts' ratings for Algoma Steel Group Inc.

Is Algoma Steel Group Inc a good investment or a top pick?

Algoma Steel Group Inc was recommended as a Top Pick by David Burrows on 2026-06-03. Read the latest stock experts ratings for Algoma Steel Group Inc.

Why is Algoma Steel Group Inc stock dropping?

Earnings reports or recent company news can cause the stock price to drop. Read stock experts' recommendations for Algoma Steel Group Inc.

Is Algoma Steel Group Inc worth watching?

Algoma Steel Group Inc is followed by 88 investors on Stockchase and is a trending stock that is worth watching.

What is Algoma Steel Group Inc stock price?

On 2026-07-14, Algoma Steel Group Inc (ASTL.TO) stock closed at a price of $5.15.

Star iconStar iconStar iconStar empty iconStar empty icon
3(4)
Based on 4 expert opinions: 2 buy 0 hold 2 sell