Stock price when the opinion was issued
They did $18.6 million EBITDA in the 1st quarter. They’re involved in contract drilling in Canada and the US, with 51 rigs in Canada and 5 in the US. They have 66 well servicing rigs. Under $2, this is a Buy, but under $1.90, it is a table pounding buy. He has a one-year target of $4.80. (Analysts’ price target is $3.50.)
(A Top Pick June 12, 2017. Down 48.76%). This is a driller. Oil service stocks are always more volatile. The drillers are all cheap now. This is on his Action Alert buy list. The company’s book value is $4.19. He has a $2.50 one-year target. This stock traded at $11 in 2014. In bull markets these stocks have a high beta. Western doesn’t have a debt problem. It owes $265 debt compared to $386 in equity. This is lower than Calfrac and Precision. Western’s biggest lender is AIMCO, which knows the oil industry well. AIMCO is also an investor in Western.
(A Top Pick July 28, 2017. Down 23%). This is quiet money. It’s a driller. Its book value is $4.15, which is much higher than its trading price. This is a Canadian driller with only 3 rigs in the United States. Its price hasn’t improved because it is locked in Canada. The AECO price (http://www.gasalberta.com/gas-market/market-prices?p=pricing-market.htm) is about $2 but will be $2.75 to $3.00 by Q4. Similarly, the NYMEX price (https://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/NG_PRI_FUT_S1_D.htm) was up a nickel today even as oil went down, could by $4 by Q4.
The company is very cheap in terms of price to book. Their book value was $4 at the end of June. However, they have a debt problem: $211 million of debt compared to an equity value of $369 million. He sees this as a takeover candidate especially now because he is seeing consolidation in the rig industry. When the industry turns around, this company will be very profitable. Utilizations rates go from 20% to 70% or 80% and much of the increased cash is profit. In addition, when rigs are busy, rig suppliers have pricing power. So, there can be an increase of 10x in profitability.
Typically service companies offer more upside than producers. If he is correct in his oil call of $55-$60, that will increase field activity because a lot of plays will work. He doesn’t see much upside above $60 in the next 1-2 years. In that environment there is still ample capacity in tier 1 drilling rigs, but companies will not have near the same pricing power as they would have coming out of a regular cycle. He is tempted on the valuation of this company, but it is not quite there for him. Liquidity can be a real issue on this one. The dividend is at risk of being cut if oil is anywhere remotely close to where we are now.